Churchill and the Zionist Movement | Avraham Seth

The Giant from Hillel Street

Once upon a time, before the word "luxury" became a profession and before every balcony...

Where are we going from here?

Where do we go from here? To the Rose Road or the Road of the Shrouds? To the Hathatim Road or the Smiles? To the Road of the Formation or...

 Youth in Haifa during the Jewish Revolt

The period of the Hebrew rebellion between the years 1945-1946 for youth in general and for youth in Haifa...

Making Souls: Poetry, music, and creativity connect emotions and open a door to the world of those struggling with the soul.

Approximately 80 cultural, art and discourse events will be held across the country...

Ido Minkowski in a candid interview • The speaker who became a singer and the strategist who is not afraid to dream big

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

Suspect arrested in shooting incident on Yad Labanim Road in Haifa – update

The Israel Police told Haifa: Haifa police officers arrested...

Environmental activists challenge the felling of 21 eucalyptus trees in Kiryat Haim

(Hai Fa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) –...

60 NIS compensation due to lack of accessibility at the "Cinema Cafe Amami" cinema in Haifa

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

Following the situation in the country where leaders declare that they, and they alone, saved/are saving/will save the country, in these difficult days. Attached is an article "On Churchill and the Zionist Movement" written by the engineer Abraham Set, a former executive at an electric company, who wrote several serious and interesting articles about the Middle East… (which were published in the monthly magazine I edit called 4XBulletin for the "Israeli Communications Association").

I found it appropriate to forward the article to "Hai Fe" and I am sure that readers will be interested in it and enjoy reading it.
Additional details about the author appear at the end of the article.
Yours, Naftali.

introduction: In the much literature written about Churchill, the argument that he was a Zionist is repeated. At first glance, this is not obvious, due to the struggle of the Jewish community against Britain at the end of the Mandate in Israel. However, following his actions and speeches shows that he played a decisive role in the establishment of the State of Israel – both due to his sympathetic personal opinion, and due to his stubborn confrontation with Nazi Germany in World War II. From a consequential point of view and supported by historical facts, if it were not for the resilience of Britain under Churchill's leadership in 1940, the chances of the establishment of the State of Israel would have been small to non-existent.

Chapter 1: Churchill's Roots and Attitude to Zionism

Was Churchill really a Zionist? Yes. Churchill showed a clear sympathy for Zionism and the Jewish people throughout most of his life. He admired Jews, enjoyed the company of Jews, and believed in a national home for the Jewish people. He was not a Zionist, he once said, but he was "connected with Zionism." Some also say that he called himself on other occasions a "passionate Zionist."

  • The roots: His sympathy stemmed from a combination of biblical faith, a deep appreciation for Jewish contributions to Western culture, and close personal ties with Jewish leaders (such as Chaim Weizmann).
  • הצהרת בלפור: In 1921, during his visit to Palestine as Colonial Secretary, Churchill emphasized Britain's commitment to the Jewish people, as enshrined in the Balfour Declaration. Churchill made it clear that the Jewish people's right to a national home in Israel was rooted in their historical right and assured the Arabs that Jewish immigration to Israel would not result in their being dispossessed of their lands.
  • The 1939 White Paper: When the British government published the "White Paper" that severely restricted Jewish immigration on the eve of the war, Churchill sharply attacked it in Parliament, calling it a "breach of trust."
  • Country support: He supported the establishment of the "Jewish Brigade" during World War II and the idea of ​​a Jewish state, sometimes in opposition to the position of the Foreign Office and the British generals, who were mostly pro-Arab.

Chapter 2: The Hour of Testing – May-June 1940

Three fateful days for the future of Europe took place starting on May 26, 1940. On that day, the British War Cabinet met, which included seven key figures: Winston Churchill as Prime Minister, Neville Chamberlain (previous Prime Minister), Lord Halifax (Foreign Secretary), Archibald Sinclair (Leader of the Liberal Party), Clement Attlee and Arthur Greenwood, representatives of the Labor Party, and Cabinet Secretary Sir Edward Bridges, who took the minutes.

The question that the cabinet discussed for several days was fateful: whether to accept the dubious peace offer and maneuver a disengagement from the war, or to reject it and continue fighting, with a heavy risk of young British soldiers being killed in a war that by all indications seemed lost, and with the hope that perhaps such an agreement would save many lives.

To understand the magnitude of the hour, it is worth noting what difficult "cards" Churchill had in his possession before making the decision:

  • German forces took control of Paris and penetrated the French defenses with humiliating ease.
  • Hitler's Panzer tanks raced into the Lands of Humiliation and broke through the difficult-to-penetrate gorges of the Ardennes Forest.
  • The Maginot Line, in the construction of which huge sums of money were invested, was easily breached.
  • The British Expeditionary Force to France was besieged in an enclave in the Channel Ports area, in danger of annihilation, and awaiting a desperate evacuation from Dunkirk.
  • Czechoslovakia ceased to exist and Poland was crushed.
  • Hitler conquered Norway while piling obstacles on the British, and captured Denmark in a little over four hours.
  • The Netherlands surrendered and the King of Belgium raised a white flag, after Germany had swallowed Austria two years earlier.
  • After the occupation of France, the Vichy regime collaborated with the Nazis and controlled Syria and Lebanon.

The most significant geostrategic problem in May 1940 was that Britain was alone and had no immediate prospect of getting help. Mussolini had entered into the "Alliance of Steel" with Hitler, the Russians had signed the "Ribbentrop-Molotov" Pact in which both sides agreed to divide Poland, and the Americans were allergic to any further European war after losing some 56,000 soldiers in World War I.

The offer and the difficult choice Lord Halifax, the Foreign Secretary, argued passionately that Mussolini's Fascist Italy should be considered as a mediator between Britain and Germany. His argument was pragmatic, as it were: "If we offer reason and mediation now, we may be able to preserve the independence of the British Empire and the British Navy before we suffer a crushing and decisive blow."

Churchill immediately recognized the trap: opening negotiations with Hitler would not save Britain, but would break the fighting spirit of the people and the army, and turn Britain into a helpless protectorate. He knew that as soon as Britain accepted any offer of mediation from the Italians, the remnants of resistance would weaken, an invisible white flag would be raised over Britain, and the willingness to continue fighting would disappear. Despite the difficult situation, he believed that Germany could not win on both fronts at the same time, but he was unable to convince his opponents in those discussions and in fact it was a dead end. At this point he declared that the meeting was closed, and that it would reconvene at seven in the evening. Then he called together all 25 cabinet ministers, and asked them to consider his position. During the meeting he said his immortal words: "If the story of our island is to come to an end, may it end only when each of us lies on the ground and chokes on his own blood." His words aroused enthusiasm and support from all the ministers, which strengthened him and resulted in the debate being concluded when the meeting resumed at seven o'clock. Halifax abandoned his position and Churchill had clear and vocal support from the cabinet.

If Britain had signed a peace treaty or bowed to Nazi pressure, the scenario for Zionism and the Land of Israel would have been catastrophic. Without Britain as a forward base, the US would not have been able to open a Western Front in Europe (the Normandy invasion). Germany would have been free to concentrate all its power against the Soviet Union, and the Nazis would have completed the "Final Solution" in Europe unhindered. 

 This table concisely summarizes the two scenarios that were at the center of the debate.

AspectBritish surrender scenario in 1940The actual result (Churchill's leadership)
The fate of the settlement in IsraelPhysical destruction by Axis forces and the MuftiDefense of the country, the establishment of the "Hagana" and the brigade
The international arenaNazi/Fascist control of Europe and the Middle EastAllied victory and the establishment of the United Nations
British leadershipA government of appeasement towards Nazi Germany and a pro-Arab and anti-Zionist policy.Churchill curbs anti-Zionist policies in the government

Britain's survival in 1940 under Churchill was a necessary condition (Condition sine qua non) for the continued existence of the Jewish people in the Land of Israel and for the establishment of the state in 1948.

Chapter 3: The Campaign in the Western Desert and the Battles of El Alamein

Churchill's decision of 1940 did not remain confined to the borders of the British Isles. As the war continued, the front expanded to North Africa and the Middle East. As will become clear here, Churchill's leadership was given a second chance to save the Jewish settlement in Israel.

In 1942, the "Afrika Korps" forces under the command of General Erwin Rommel, rushed east towards Egypt and Suez. When the German armor took advantage of the vast desert to surround the British forces and push them east towards Egypt, the goal was to continue from there towards the oil sources of Iraq and its neighbors, while taking care of the Jewish population in Israel along the way. This, in addition to the fear of the German advance from the Caucasus region. For the Jewish population in Israel (about 500,000 people) this situation posed a threat of immediate physical annihilation and this period was called the "200 Days of Terror", what's more, some British commanders planned a retreat towards Iraq, Hajj Amin al-Husseini, the Mufti of Jerusalem, made an explicit alliance with Hitler and waited for the entry of Nazi forces to carry out the "Final Solution" on the Jews of Israel.

Regarding the treatment plans for the Jews of Israel, documents found after the end of the war testify. According to them, during the fighting, Walter Rauf, the SS officer who was responsible for operating the trucks for killing with exhaust gases, was in Tunis at that time. In addition, 24 SS soldiers who had undergone training in killing with exhaust gases were waiting in Greece. The group was called "Einsatzgruppe Egypt" and was apparently intended to exterminate the Jews of Israel with the help of volunteers from the region.

The turning point at El Alamein (October-November 1942) Churchill understood the immense strategic importance of the Suez Canal and the Middle East. He changed military command and entrusted the campaign to General Bernard Montgomery, who immediately upon taking office announced the cancellation of the withdrawal plans.

In the Second Battle of El Alamein, the British Eighth Camp, in which thousands of volunteers from the Jewish community in Palestine also fought, halted and defeated the Axis forces.

The direct connection to the establishment of the state

  1. Physical rescue: The victory at El Alamein prevented the "El Alamein scenario" of the destruction of the settlement, and left the Jewish community in the land alive, organized, and constructive.
  2. Building the military force: This period allowed for the establishment of the Jewish Brigade and the intensification of training for the "Hagana" and the Palmach (as part of the "Two Hundred Days of Terror" program and cooperation with the British), an operational experience that was critical and decisive later in the War of Independence in 1948.
  3. International base: If it were not for Britain's resistance in 1940 and the victory at El Alamein in 1942, the international coalition that defeated the Nazis would not have been created, and the United Nations Council would not have been established, which adopted the partition resolution on November 29, 1947.

Chapter 4: Summary and Conclusions: From Churchill's Legacy to Promoting the Establishment of the State.

The importance of leadership at the moment of decision When examining the process of the establishment of the State of Israel, it is customary to focus on the settlement struggle, the diplomatic activity of the Zionist leadership, and the local threats of war. However, a broad and in-depth historical perspective shows that the cornerstone for the establishment of the state was laid in those fateful three days in May 1940, in the deliberation rooms of the British War Cabinet.

Winston Churchill's passionate Zionism was not expressed only in his sympathetic statements or his consistent support for Aliyah and the Jewish Brigade. It was realized first and foremost in his resolute resistance and absolute refusal to surrender to Nazism, a determination that saved the entire free world, including the Jewish revival project in the Land of Israel.

Key conclusions:

  1. The necessary condition (Without which): Had it not been for Britain's stand in 1940, the Axis powers would have taken control of the Middle East, and the Jewish settlement in Israel (as the remaining central Jewish representation) would have been physically destroyed by the Nazis and their aides.
  2. Preventing an "al-Al-Alameen scenario": The military victory at the Battle of El Alamein in 1942, made possible thanks to Churchill's determination to maintain a strong front in the Western Desert, maintained the continuity of the Yishuv, strengthened its independent military force (the brigade and the "Hagana") and prepared it for the state test in 1948.
  3. The international political basis: The British victory and the coalition that emerged in its wake laid the foundation for the establishment of the United Nations and the adoption of the partition resolution on November 29, 1947. Without this victory, the international system that recognized the Jewish people's right to a state would not have existed.

The importance of the argument for historical research Despite the friction and intense conflict that arose between the Jewish community and the British government at the end of the Mandate, historical facts prove that without Churchill's figure and leadership in 1940, the chances of establishing the State of Israel were slim to nonexistent. In the end, his uncompromising leadership not only changed the face of world history, but served as the critical bridge that enabled the rebirth of the Jewish people in their own land.

The writer: Avraham Set – Technion graduate in electrical engineering (1962), specialist engineer in the Electrical Engineering Division of the Israel Electric Corporation, retired in 2002. Main specializations: computer applications in electrical engineering, power system analysis, knowledge of the Middle East's electrical systems, connecting national electrical systems. Served in the reserves in the Intelligence Corps' research division.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the Hai system here: At watsap • By email

Naphtali in white
Naphtali in white
Writer and poet, secretary of the Association of Writers in Haifa and the North, former high-tech person and manager of Beit Miller in Haifa

More articles from the same reporter

3 תגובות

  1. Excellent article!!
    In light of the recent wave of anti-Semitism and hatred of Israel that has been rising in certain circles in various countries on the European continent, including most recently England, "the (former) empire on which the sun never set," and which is threatening us with severe economic sanctions, my suggestion is to quickly translate this article into English and urgently send a copy to each and every member of the British government. For generations, Churchill has stood on the threshold of privileged and high leadership throughout Europe, and especially so in the consciousness and history of England. It is fitting that the various British politicians take another look back and learn another layer from the views, opinions, and actions of this great leader of theirs on the subject of Jews in general and Israelis in particular. If such a look succeeds in tilting even slightly the pendulum of hatred and evil in the opposite direction toward understanding and empathy for us, then our reward on the subject of 'hasbara' will be a wise and worthy achievement.

  2. I have known Avraham for many years (remembering his wedding with Yardena at the Windsor Hotel about 60 years ago). And I didn't know about his knowledge of the history of the establishment of the state. All the best and keep posting.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Algae hazard on Bat Galim beaches • Pungent odor, concern about gas emissions and complaints of illness among bathers

(Live News Corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - Residents and bathers on Bat Galim beaches in Haifa are warning of a prolonged accumulation of large amounts of algae, which remain...

The labor dispute at Haifa Port continues

(Live from Haifa News Corporation and the surrounding area) - The labor dispute at the Haifa Port continues. The Histadrut declared a labor dispute last week, following a series of disputes...

Between history and neglect • Shmuel Itzkovich Square and its steps were forgotten from the heart of the city

(Live here, Haifa News Corporation and the surrounding area) - Shmuel Itzkovich Square and the staircase system connecting Herzl Street and Hehalutz Street, on the way to the Talpiot Market area, are...

Lotem Stream • The dangerous rocks are still on the slope and the hazard has not yet been removed.

(Live here, Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) - Months of complaints, professional tours and instructions from the Haifa Municipality, but the safety hazard in Nahal Lotem has not yet been removed....

Public warning • Fake SMS messages impersonating official traffic fines

(Haifa News Corporation and the surrounding area) - The Israel Police warns of a wave of false messages distributed in recent hours via text messages (SMS), including demands for payment...