The battle for Margalit 23 continues – the committee rejected a reservation

(Hai Fa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) –...

The Mana Katz Museum and Milav Club in the Carmel Center Face Prolonged Neglect

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - Buildings...

Rabies spreads in Israel • Woman fights for her life and fears of deadly outbreak grow

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

First Haifa Marathon – 20.11.26: Update on roadblocks and medical and police preparedness

(Hai Fa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) –...

A precedent-setting lawsuit against offensive discourse regarding Arab society

(Live here - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) -...

The crybaby on duty

The crying man on duty just woke up from his sleep and immediately "sanded" the remains of his sleep. After...

Flower of the week • Shooting star

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column we will represent...

Meshulam House – Modernism Hidden from View

At 7 Hanadiv Blvd., in the heart of the Shambor neighborhood on the Carmel, behind...

Second-hand: The trend that gives clothes new life

Between the changing collections and the trends that demand space in the wardrobe,...

Cafe-Tzur in Acre • A period when the north of the country competed bravely against the center

A young, sturdy redhead, fluent in Arabic, succeeded during the austerity period...

The battle for Margalit 23 continues – the committee rejected a reservation

(Hai Fa – Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) The struggle over construction policy in the Shambor neighborhood in Haifa reached another boiling point this week, after the plenary session of the local Planning and Building Committee rejected the reservations submitted by Deputy Mayor and Green Party Chairman Avihu Hahn and Council member Moti Blitzblau regarding the project at 23 Margalit Street. At the heart of the dispute is the question of whether construction that deviates from the municipal policy document can be approved, or whether decisions of this type empty the established policy of its content and undermine public trust in the planning system.

One project that became a symbol of a broader struggle

The debate surrounding Margalit 23 is not just about one building. For opponents of the plan, it is a fundamental test of whether the city of Haifa has a binding planning policy, or whether it can be circumvented time and again through exceptions and exemptions.

The approved plan includes the construction of a 6.5-story building in the Shambor neighborhood. Opponents claim that this is a deviation from the municipal policy document intended to preserve the character of the neighborhood. On the other hand, supporters of the project claim that this is a reasonable plan required to promote urban renewal and provide housing solutions.

The plenary's decision to reject the reservation provoked strong reactions from the Green Party and the neighborhood's residents, who see the decision as a precedent that could affect additional projects in the future.

Avihu Han: The exception has become the rule

Avihu Han (Photo: Yaron Karmi)
Avihu Han (Photo: Yaron Karmi)

After the vote, Avihu Han announced that he intends to file an appeal with the Haifa District Appeals Committee. According to him, the problem is not just the specific building but the broader trend. He claims that whenever a plan is submitted that exceeds the height limits set in the policy documents, special reasons are presented that allow it to be approved.

For him, when every request becomes a special case, it means that the exception has effectively become the actual policy.

Hahn argues that the policy documents are intended to protect the quality of life of residents and the character of neighborhoods, and therefore must be respected. He says that if they can be deviated from in every case, the question arises as to why the policy documents were prepared in the first place.

The conflict over the meaning of the policy document

At the heart of the debate is the interpretation of the 2020 municipal policy document. According to this document, the Shambor neighborhood is defined as a texture preservation area. The definition means imposing restrictions on the height of new buildings in order to preserve the unique character of the neighborhood.

According to opponents of the project, the document sets a ceiling of only 5.5 floors. In addition, the policy document for TAMA 38 allows for a maximum of six floors, with the top floor supposed to be set back. Therefore, they claim, approving a 6.5-story building constitutes a clear deviation from the established policy. Professionals and developers, on the other hand, believe that there is a possibility of examining individual cases in which a certain deviation from the height limits can be justified.

Neighborhood residents are fighting for the character of Shambor

The struggle over Margalit 23 is not new. In recent months, residents of the Shambor neighborhood have held demonstrations and protest actions against various urban renewal projects, which they claim are changing the character of the neighborhood. The residents claim that they are not opposed to urban renewal in principle, but they ask that construction be carried out in accordance with the established policy and not become an uncontrolled race to maximize building rights. According to them, any additional deviation in the height of buildings creates a precedent on which other developers will base themselves in the future, until eventually the special character of the neighborhood is completely lost.

Zvika Barbie: Unnecessary pressure is being exerted on the entrepreneur

At the local committee meeting, completely different voices were also heard. City Council member Zvika Barbie came to the developer's defense, claiming that the authorities were harassing him for only half a floor. Barbie claimed that for months the developer had been required to undergo additional procedures, discussions, and inspections, when in reality it was a minor difference in the building's height.

He said it makes no sense that in other parts of the city, buildings of similar or even greater heights are approved, while in this case additional difficulties and restrictions are imposed. He also argued that such conduct harms the ability to promote construction in the city and offer housing solutions for both young and old.

Is increased construction the key to keeping young people in Haifa?

One of the main issues raised in the discussion concerns Haifa's future and its ability to maintain a young population.

Supporters of the project argue that high housing prices and limited housing supply require the city to allow more intensive construction. According to them, any delay in urban renewal projects reduces the possibility of young couples finding housing solutions in the city.

On the other hand, Avihu Hahn and environmental activists claim that it is precisely preserving the character of neighborhoods, green lungs, and a high quality of life that will attract young families to Haifa. According to them, responsible planning is not opposed to urban renewal, but rather constitutes a condition for its long-term existence.

The history of the struggle against planning committees

The current discussion is just another chapter in a long chain of discussions. In July 2026, the issue reached the local committee plenary following a previous reservation submitted by the Green faction. At that discussion, Avihu Hahn demanded that construction be limited to only six floors. Mayor Yona Yahav indicated at the time that this was the desired direction, and the issue was returned to the subcommittee for further consideration.

However, in October 2026, the subcommittee once again approved the construction of the 6.5-story building, which led to another objection from Hahn and Blitzblau. They claimed that the subcommittee ignored the spirit of the plenary resolution and municipal policy.

The issue of public trust

Beyond the planning questions, opponents also raise the issue of public trust.

According to Han, it is not possible for residents and environmental activists to have to constantly monitor every permit and every plan to ensure that the policy is being implemented. According to him, city residents should feel confident that the authorities are acting according to the rules that have been set in advance. When deviations from planning policy are approved time and time again, he claims that the public's faith in the city's policy is indeed binding is damaged.

A broader struggle over the future of the Carmel Range

Margalit 23 is just one of a series of projects that are stirring controversy in the Carmel Range.

In recent years, the question of urban renewal has become one of the central issues in Haifa. On the one hand, there is a growing demand to strengthen old buildings, add elevators and ramps, and increase the supply of housing. On the other hand, there is concern about harming the landscape, overcrowding, old trees, and the quality of life of residents.

Between these two poles, there is an ongoing struggle that repeatedly reaches the committee tables, the courts, and the appeals committees.

Now, after the rejection of the reservation in the local committee plenum, it appears that the next battle will take place in the district appeals committee, where the opponents will try to convince that the policy document must be respected and the construction height must be limited in accordance with the principles established for the Shambor neighborhood.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the newsroom: At watsap • By email

Michal Grover
Michal Grover
Michal Grover Education reporter • Real estate • Company Contact: 054-4423911 Mail to the container: [email protected]

Articles related to this topic

9 תגובות

  1. I lived on Hayarkon Street, opposite the entrance to Kidron Street. The area is well known to me. It would be a shame not to preserve the wild landscape, a green lung.

  2. Every word of architect Blumenfeld is accurate... although unfortunately the municipality has also absorbed plans that do not meet any minimum standards, and in doing so it is aiding criminality as it "allows" completion, repair and modification... and so on, once again rolling out the red carpet for developers... and all this before the next masterpiece is published... the building. And without the neighborhoods coming together for a joint struggle. Complaining here will not help.

  3. Taking a single building, demolishing it, cutting down all the vegetation around it, and erecting a new building in its place, tripling the number of apartments and without expanding infrastructure or public buildings – this is not “urban renewal.” This is the systematic destruction of the Carmel.

    If they had ensured that TAMA 38 would only be approved for buildings that actually meet the eligibility conditions, the demolition we are witnessing would not have progressed with such momentum. Years ago, we proposed another solution, as part of David Etzioni's election platform: the transfer of building rights. Through such a mechanism, it would have been possible to renew and upgrade the construction in Carmel, while preserving its unique character, the urban fabric, and the existing construction fabric. We did not invent anything - this mechanism exists in Tel Aviv, and has existed for over a hundred years in cities in the West. This way, the building rights could have been channeled to the appropriate places, instead of concentrating all the real estate pressure precisely in the most sensitive areas. However, when he was not elected, his plans were also shelved, even though they contained worthy and good ideas.

    A year and a half or more of hard work, with the participation of all municipal departments and the assistance of external consultants, was invested in formulating the 2020 policy. This comprehensive professional work was dissolved before the ink had dried on the paper on which it was written.

    My heart aches as I walk the streets of Carmel: construction on every corner, cranes, destruction of vegetation, and alongside all this dirt, neglect, and filth. Every morning I hear news about good young families considering leaving the city. Is anyone really deluding themselves that this construction boom will stop negative immigration? There is nothing between reckless construction and stopping immigration. Positive immigration will only come through increasing employment opportunities, developing sources of income, and creating a city worth living in.

    But this is not the direction the city is heading. A situation has arisen in which the municipality desperately needs revenue, and the property tax collected – almost twice as high as that paid in Tel Aviv – is not sufficient. In such a reality, when TAMA 38 is an available source of revenue for the municipality's coffers, economic considerations outweigh considerations of planning, quality of life, and preserving the character of the Carmel.

    The proliferation of new buildings being built under TAMA 38 without allocating public areas creates sleeping cities. Anyone who wants to leave the house has difficulty getting around because of endless traffic jams. He can only walk aimlessly up and down hills, because there is nowhere to go. He is imprisoned in his home.

    In anticipation of the expiration of TAMA 38 in Haifa, on May 18, 2026, hundreds of applications were submitted under it throughout the city, especially in Carmel. Many of them were submitted hastily, without planning maturity and relying on planning that had not yet been completed. Instead of utilizing the remaining time to examine the applications in a professional, informed, and responsible manner, there was actually a rush to approve them by the municipality. In anticipation of this date, the municipality waived documents that were required by it as a threshold condition for accepting a permit application under TAMA 38 and was satisfied with only what was required by law.

    The developers are not to blame. They are operating within the framework of the options that the local authority presents to them. The responsibility lies with the municipality, which failed to channel the economic and entrepreneurial potential into the right planning directions. Instead of managing urban renewal, defining its boundaries, and directing it so that it serves the good of the city and its residents, it allowed market forces to dictate the future of the Carmel.

    The result is not urban renewal, but the gradual loss of the assets that made the Carmel a unique, sought-after, and high-quality place to live.

  4. Kiryat Eliezer is waiting for a major urban renewal. It is close to the exit to the coastal road, the hospital, and the railway. But the wretchedness of the city engineer's office is glaring when the main focus is on approving individual construction by entrepreneurs for a building here and a building there on the Carmel.
    Anyone who believes that increasing density will keep young people is ignorant and stupid. Quality of life is what Avihu defined in his arguments.

  5. Haifa Municipality: 10 million shekels for the absurd "Port of Lights" project - in Hong Kong today the real project was canceled today after 22 years.
    In Hong Kong, they realized that this does not contribute to tourism, is a waste of electricity, and causes terrible light pollution.
    And Haifa-Helem? Someone in the mayor's circle is pushing to throw 10 million shekels in the trash for a failed and unnecessary project. It's time to turn off the power to it here too. Invest in local culture.

  6. Also at 6 Yaffe Nof Street and 15 President Boulevard, a plan was submitted to build a tiny lot. Instead of 2 low-rise buildings, 2 stories, they want to build 2 buildings with 6.5 stories. Horrible construction that destroys the character of the streets, traffic congestion, reducing the spaces between houses, putting children at risk in a nearby kindergarten, including not being included. All objections were rejected. A victory for the developers, a loss for the residents and this city that is changing its face into concrete ugliness.

  7. Barbie is only temporary and assumes that at the end of the term no one will elect him and he will be left without a job. I have never seen such a representative in my life. A poverty certificate for voters.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Renewal of renovation and maintenance work at the Gadiv plant of the Bazan Group has been approved

(Hai Pa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) - The Ministry of Environmental Protection notified the management of the Gadiv plant of the Bazan Group in Haifa Bay on Tuesday (11/17/26) about...

Fewer children, fewer young families: Data on Haifa children revealed

(Hai Pa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) – On the occasion of International Children's Day, the Central Bureau of Statistics publishes a collection of data on the child population in Israel for the year...

The crybaby on duty

The crying man had just woken up from his sleep and was about to "sand off" the remnants of his sleep. After washing his face with tears and wiping his eyes with a wet cloth, he glanced out the window of his apartment and saw how she was sliding...

Record obesity among children in Israel

(Haifa News Corporation) - The Community Medicine Quality Indicators report indicates a worrying figure. The obesity rate among seven-year-old children has reached...

Flower of the week • Shooting star

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column, we will always present one of the Carmel flowers, at the same time as it appears in the field, and you will be invited to visit it in one of the places where...