(Haipo) – This opinion column examines the sensitive issue of integrating armed Arab police officers into police stations in the Arab sector. Despite decades of successful service by Arab police officers in the Israel Police, their representation rate remains far below their share in the population. It's time to change that❗️
Representation gap and structural discrimination
The Arab population of the State of Israel constitutes approximately 22% of the total population, but the proportion of police officers from the Arab sector employed in police stations in the sector is only seven to eight percent, or perhaps even less. This is real discrimination, which works against the national interest of the State of Israel.
The reasoning given over the years was that the number of residents in each settlement was low and therefore it was not possible to station police officers in every village, and instead several settlements were consolidated under one station. However, the stigmas and prejudices regarding giving weapons to Arab citizens are the basis of the gap, despite the fact that the Israel Police has been proving for some 78 years – and even during the Mandate period – that it is possible to recruit Arab police officers who perform their duties loyally and successfully.
Fighting Organized Crime – A Change in Legislative and Enforcement Approach
To combat organized crime in the Arab sector, a combined approach of intelligence and strict legislation is required.
The first step is to make the mere act of belonging to a crime family a serious offense, similar to belonging to a terrorist organization.
The second step is to increase the penalty for illegal possession of weapons: a mandatory eight-year prison sentence and a fine of one million shekels. Hitting the pocketbook is the most effective measure, because people join crime families primarily because they want to make more money.
Preventive measures should be taken against those who are known to be targets of harm – not arrest, but restricting freedom of movement through electronic monitoring. This way, that person can lead a normal life and go to work, but without endangering the general public.
Breaking Stigma – From the Druze and Bedouin to the entire Arab sector
Today it sounds strange, but years ago, Druze and Bedouin were still opposed to the conscription, and in practice, these two sectors proved to be a successful combination – a Druze brigade was established in the IDF, and Bedouins served as outstanding scouts.
A significant portion of the Israel Police force today includes police officers from the Arab sector, and they are proving themselves in the field.
It is easy for Israeli society to shout about ultra-Orthodox evasion of conscription, but for some reason they ignore the fact that an entire 22% of the public does not contribute its share to the security effort.
If 100,000 Arab citizens were to serve in the police or the National Guard, this would be a huge increase in manpower that would increase the level of security, both in Arab communities and in mixed communities (like Haifa, for example).
Equality in duties and rights – the path to a more protected society
Integrating Israeli Arabs into the service solves two problems at the same time: it increases equality and also strengthens identification with the state, as those who are involved in the work feel that they are contributing and that they are an integral part of society.
Equality should be complete – mainly in rights, but also in duties. Just as it is right to violate the rights of Haredim who do not serve, so should anyone who does not contribute their share.
It is precisely minorities – both Arabs and Haredim – who demonstrate a high level of education and a desire to excel, as can be seen in the high percentage of Israeli Arabs in hospitals.
In conclusion, the message is clear: if we break the ideological stalemate and allow conscription for every person according to law, Israeli society will be more protected, safer, and more equal.


The phenomenon of Jews who are no longer politically relevant in the public and who receive huge pensions from the state, who express themselves and sometimes make puzzling headlines, apparently did not escape Yaakov Borovsky.
I take back the description "who are no longer politically relevant". They may indeed be relevant among some of the public, and in any case, they have the right to express their opinion.
Wow, to think that I supported you for mayor at the time..
Who among you will take responsibility for the dilemma that those police officers you propose to recruit in large numbers will be the ones who will start wall-guarding incidents here again? Again a return to the concept? Again naivety?
Another delusion that I recently discovered is that the police also allow those who did not serve in the army to join the police? The country here has completely gone off the rails. In my opinion, anyone who was not a fighter in a combat unit and did not fight terrorists should be disqualified outright! And it doesn't matter what sector they are from!
Hospitals? There is always this naivety in mentioning their integration into hospitals as if it were volunteering or military service and not salaries, in some cases tens of thousands of shekels a month.
Instead of writing about the state's discrimination that allows studies and admission to government hospitals and the police even to those who have not served in the army for 3 years, you are preparing the insult of our warriors that while they dedicate 3 years of their lives to defending the homeland, there are those whom the state allows to study at educational institutions within its borders during this time and even to be accepted into public positions!?
And why don't you write about the discrimination in our city where 13% of minorities allow, for example, 38% of them to fill medical positions at Rambam and as of 2021, 15.6% of them hold positions in the Haifa Municipality.
Why don't you record the discrimination in their favor in these jobs and the discrimination of the other residents who live in Haifa according to your integration scenario?
There has never been any stigma regarding Druze, especially since many of them serve in the security forces with honor, neither with Christians nor with Muslims, and for many years the entire sector has served with honor in the Israeli government.
How many religious and ultra-Orthodox police officers are there in the Israel Police?
Why don't you call for combining them?!
The question is whether Arabs want to serve in the police.