The personal and historical stories of the city are its soul and important for its future
Reading street and city names should be part of the local, social and national narrative. The streets dedicated throughout Haifa's history represent, among other things, the unique diversity of the population in Haifa, the distribution of honor in the Haifa context and the meanings of the local story.
about wisdom and sensitivity
Every year, "Jane's Walks" are held around the world and in Haifa, named after Jane Jacobs, a Canadian journalist who turned the local and private memories and stories into an urban asset of the city. Jain walks have become a representation of the soul of the city thanks to their versatility and the personal tone woven into the local history. These can and should be leveraged, but like everything, it must be done wisely and sensitively, as it must be done in a complex and diverse city like Haifa.
All the commemorations and honors
Street reading and commemoration in Haifa as a platform for political populism
Recently, the reading of streets and squares in Haifa has become an expression of mysterious whims in the vicinity of the mayor's office. The Haifa story has become cheap literature that has no historical understanding or even the appearance of an attempt to investigate it. Unknown parties are stirring up the contemporary urban commemoration and recognition scene, elevating marginal figures and presenting them as Haifa pride, or flattering nationalists, some of whom themselves do not understand their connection to Haifa. Thus, among other things, Yehoram Gaon earned a street named after him in his lifetime. Maybe because of his ex-wife, who grew up in Haifa? Karin Goren and Ilanit Levy have been chosen to grace the Carmel Center for many months, due to the fact that they were born in Haifa (who left it when they reached adulthood). The feeling is that Haifa is becoming a provincial extension of the program "Arab Tov with Guy Pines".
Haifa pride?
Impressive forces emerged from Haifa, from the leaders in innovation in the Israeli and international reality, in various and varied fields. Under the current leadership, under the auspices of the mayor's office, it seems that there is no need for so much to be chosen as a symbol of Haifa pride displayed on the streets. It is enough to participate in populist or gossipy TV programs and especially in idle talk, advertisements, expertise in cakes or participation in a reality show.
Streets in the new Zemar neighborhood are named after singers in their lifetime, who never had any connection to Haifa. It is not clear to them themselves how they received this honor and how exactly in Haifa they decided to name a street after them. On the other hand, female artists and other artists, who lived in Haifa or for whom the city is an integral part of their work - did not receive this. The decisions are made from above and the reasons are kept with those who decided to act this way.

Ignorance of Haifa history leads to ridiculous decisions
As part of the urban populism operations, a decision was recently published by the same creative house in the mayor's office: to change part of Halutz Street to be called "Pioneer Street", under the pretext of a feminist amendment to the figure of the pioneer. The problem with the whole story is that Halutz Street was named after the "Halutz" movement and not because of a particular pioneer, and thus it seems that the decision was made on the basis of ignorance and lack of knowledge of the history of the Zionist movement, therefore it was also accepted with ridicule and anger among the general public and among experts on the subject.
For the information of the decision-making authority: the "Pioneer" movement was a worldwide Zionist movement of young Jewish men and women, who organized themselves for the purpose of immigrating to the Land of Israel. It began with spontaneous organizations in the 80s of the 19th century, and it existed until the Holocaust. The members of the Halutz, who belonged to various Zionist youth movements, were at the forefront of immigration and settlement in the Land of Israel and of the Jewish defense in the Diaspora, including in the ghettos where the Jews were concentrated during World War II.
The Facebook of the pioneer
For a moment it seemed that the strange decision was frozen and dropped from the episode, but a few days ago I was invited to join the Facebook page of the complex called "The Pioneer Complex". It turns out that some party, whose name is unknown, decided to demarcate several streets (bearing the names of men) at the beginning of Halutz Street in the vicinity of HaNaviim Street and turn it into the "Halutz Complex". In the picture of the sign that was published it says: "In honor of the first home of pioneers that operated in Hadar Carmel in the 1930s and in honor of generations of pioneers who worked for the building of the city."
Honoring the pioneer and the home of the pioneers could have been important and right, but here too things are carried out negligently, with a lack of knowledge and lack of learning and "extractions" for the purposes of populism and public relations that nullify proper administration, by sewing a gender that is not of its gender while alienating the real facts and creating injustice and historical distortions that harm the heritage and story of Haifa. In the case described, it is also not clear who even initiated it and by what authority?
"Pioneer Compound"
The historical facts about the Beit Halutz complex and how they turn the important story into a bad joke
A little about the history of the place promoted by any parties under the name "Pioneer Complex": the complex surrounds a square consisting of several streets, between Herzl, Yoel, Shmariahu Levin and Halutz Streets. In the years before the establishment of the state in the last century and into the 50s, the neighborhood whose borders were demarcated between Yona, Shmariahu Levin, the Pioneer and the Prophets streets was called Harat A(L) Schwafna (Shwafna neighborhood). The Street of the Prophets was then called Anforta. In the documentation of the National Archives there are documents from the XNUMXs that use these names. Prof. Mahmoud Yazbek from the Department of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies at the University of Haifa, explains that the origin of its name comes from the settlers in the place - immigrants from the Al-Suf mountains in Lebanon.

Absolute antithesis
The historic Beit Halutz, which is used as an excuse for commemorating the memory of the "Pioneer", is actually located at the other end of the street, at 5 Yalga Street, next to the building of the Lev Hash Association. Until a few years ago, it was also named after the organization that contributed to its construction - Beit Lanyi (Women's League for Israel). The facades of the beautiful building of the Pioneer House were neglected and vandalized in an architecturally insensitive renovation, painted ugly and surrounded by high fences to hide its occupants. The place has been used for a number of years as a school for boys in grades XNUMX-XNUMX of Belez Hassidism. Part of the building is rented as a residence for the ultra-Orthodox population. There is no trace in the building's surroundings of the building's historical story or of the pioneer women and the significance of the place. The population that inhabits it today is a complete antithesis to the story of female, historical and Zionist power.
The story of the first pioneer home in Palestine - Eretz Israel
The Pioneer House in Haifa was the first to be established in Palestine - the Land of Israel, with the aim of being a primary residence for immigrant women. The house was established on the initiative of a group of Zionist women who retired from the Hadassah Zionist Organization and wanted to establish their own enterprise in the Land of Israel.
The "Women's League for Israel" was founded in 1925 to help the settlement project in Israel. On the recommendation of Rachel Yanait Ben-Zvi, who told them about the difficulty of women finding housing at a reasonable price. The women of the organization decided to establish a pioneer home as a joint initiative of the "Women's League for the Land of Israel in America" " and the Histadrut. They began collecting funds in 1926 and collected $25,000 for the construction.
The first Beit Halutz building in the Land of Israel was opened in Haifa in 1932 at 5 Yalga St., the port city where most of the new immigrants (the pioneers) arrived. The building was designed by Binyamin Chaikon and included 21 rooms on three floors, two halls: a dining room and a library, three Workshops and a laundry on the roof of the building. In addition to living in the building, there were also cooperative initiatives that included a restaurant, a laundry, a weaving house, and a tailor. In 1936-1937, the Beit Halutz was an activity of the Etzal. For many years, a station of the public service for family care, and treatment Emotional in individuals and in the family. The place closed at some point after the beginning of the 21st century.

Cheap and embarrassing populism
The urban space is managed with a strategy of cheap and embarrassing populism and becomes a pastiche
Tossing around names and concepts that are tied to important social assets in an unrelated manner is an expression of ignorance and a cheap and embarrassing populism that is spreading with alarming speed in the current reality in Haifa.
There is no connection between those who currently study at the historic Pioneer House and the figure of the pioneer who is the absolute antithesis of their educational and social worldview. Zionism and the social values in whose name that house was founded have nothing to do with this population either. Likewise, there is no connection between "Pioneer Street" or "Pioneer Complex" to the place where the complex was announced. It does not interfere with those who came up with the idea of the complex to join a species that is not of its own kind, to take a set of streets with a very specific history, decorate with some graffiti paintings and claim that this is a tribute to the Pioneer House. Until now it is not clear to me who is responsible for this and I will bring the comments at the end of the article.
When there is a connection…
Just to illustrate, how a historical local story is connected to the present and the living community in the place: in the Emek Hafer Regional Council, the head of the council, Dr. Galit Shaul, initiated the establishment of a Beit Rishonoth in the historic Beit Rishonot complex located in Beit Aharon. The renovated house dedicated to the pioneers of the valley is a socio-economic venture, a business space for entrepreneurial, independent women and business owners.
In the Mosrara neighborhood in Jerusalem, the Black Panthers who lived and operated there are commemorated in the public space. Black Panther Street and the Alley of the Unnice. There is a connection, there is a connection and there is material for thought and learning.
The management of the urban content in Haifa today is characterized by the control and management of irresponsible parties who lead a reality of pastiche - the artificial linking of things that do not belong to each other, with a lack of thought, tastelessness and insensitivity that cause the personal story of the groups that are the soul of Haifa and the basis of its existence to be discredited: the Arab story in Haifa, The first Jewish settlements, the pioneers, the historical architects who shaped the face of Hadar and the historic city, Jewish organizations that contributed to the promotion of Zionism and contemporary social values. Mix everything and create a tasteless "mish-mesh" with content that indicates its creators more than anything else.
Erasure and trampling of the heritage of the pioneers and what they represented
I took a few photos of the school located in Beit Halutz and which is located on Yalji Street. There is no reference to the name Yalaj in this story. The street is named after the poet Yehuda Leib Gordon. Yalaj was born and lived in the 19th century, he preached a fundamental change in thought patterns and lifestyles on the Jewish street. He was a poet-warrior, who attacked the rabbinical establishment and the Hasidic identity in a sharp and stinging manner. He paid a heavy price for that. His famous, long and poignant poem is called "Tip of Iodine" and it begins with these words:
Hebrew woman who knew your life?
In the dark you came and in the dark you will go;
saddened and troubled you, broken by your woes
May your flesh be born, may your inward parts be filled.
The earth is full, all goodness and rest
To build another nation is a given virtue.
But the life of the Hebrew is eternal slavery,
She will not come out of her camp;
Arise, give birth, suckle me, reward me,
Bake and cook and do not eat at the time of your harvest.
The women who lived in Beit Halutz were the ones who went against the view described by Yalaj: they turned their backs on the ultra-Orthodox, conservative and restrictive view, which directs women to a life of biological function and help against it while diminishing and erasing themselves, dedicating all their destiny to the benefit of increased births, providing for the family and complete dedication For the benefit of the learning husband. The community currently studying in the historic Pioneer House on 13th Street is a community that is completely opposite to the pioneers, opposed to Zionism, general education, and certainly to female power and a free world view freed from the shackles of religion as the pioneers perceived it.

What does this mean about us?
What does it say about us when we neglect and turn our backs on the authentic Haifa story?
For several years now, the current city leadership has been trying to expand the Beit Halutz area in favor of a school for ultra-Orthodox girls at the expense of the building of the charity organization Lev Hash, which used to be a 13th school. How strange that the axis that embodies the Israeli renaissance: Herzl, the pioneer of the 13th century and the Haifa historical story, is trampled by the current Haifa municipality and tries to confuse public opinion by carelessly and amateurishly attaching national values to irrelevant names. In the current situation, superficiality and emptiness work overtime in the service of the municipality's leadership and dishonor the Haifa story of all of us.
delete what was
When history is erased and distorted without any problem, then it is easy to continue: damaging a magnificent concentration of local and historical architecture that had to undergo preservation for the closing of balconies and the construction of Sukkah balconies. Damage wadis, green areas, belittle social activists, entrepreneurs, turn museums into cafes, and so on. This probably allows parties on their own behalf to declare areas as a complex and promote them as if they were a municipal decision. It is not clear where the line is drawn and the lack of leadership allows for the reality of all male Dalits.
The city's leadership, which has been dealing with the disappearance of the period that preceded it since it came to power, has apparently become addicted to the ease with which it thinks it is possible to erase what happened before it. Does not exercise any thought on the social and difficult meanings arising from the cancellation of the diverse and deep history of Haifa.
In this dangerous process, the Haifa story of all its historical and social layers is erased, for populist interests and political survival, harming the soul of Haifa, its image and its future.
Comments:
Eliran Tal, spokesman for the Haifa Municipality, told Lahi Fa:
"The issue passed a decision by the Names Committee and was approved by the City Council.
Attorney Sharit Golan Steinberg, member of the city council and chairman of the names committee and the committee for historical signage and dear friends of the city of Haifa:
"Last night (Sun. 13/2/22) the decision was officially canceled because it was illegal when it was made. The way they managed the committee was promiscuous, while excluding the professionals from the city's archives. They divided streets as if it were a reality show and as if there was an endless pool of streets and as if it were not in a limited public property, which must be divided sparingly, wisely and with overall sensitivity. Even when issuing the public relations notice about changing the name of a part of Halutz Street, I said that I, as the chairman of the committee, cancel the decision and demand that an orderly request be submitted for a new name and not a name change procedure. Following my cancellation We received the decision from a legal opinion stating that the name change procedure requires prior publication and approval by two-thirds of the council, two things that were not met in this case."


Disgrace, as one whose mother was a Halutz member, I can only express anger and disgust at the municipality's behavior on the issue.
It's sad to see how Haifa, the city of my childhood and adulthood, my home port, fell into the hands of a bunch of heartless losers, who rob its residents of not only its present and future but also its past.
Excellent article Gila, thanks.
Excellent article, poignant and fair.
Thank you very much for the smart and enlightening writing
You managed in an accurate article to convey less accurate thoughts that I have about Haifa, a city that I once loved so much
Thank you very much for the interesting article Gila Livni - Zamir.
Thank you very much for the interesting and important article.
It is important to hear the voice of reason - the one that is not cultivated on the basis of populism and political conduct that only harms society in Haifa in particular and Israel in general.
It's funny that articles in various locales here in Haifa glorified the vandalism that was done several years ago when signs were hung on the names of streets with alternative names. The municipality, instead of punishing the lawbreakers, backs them up in a belligerent and mindless manner.
It's a shame that you are also politicizing. What is the connection between the former name of Haneviyim Street, or some inscription with the name Gerat El Shwafna, which you also mention is a complex on Yona Street, and the Pioneer House on 13th Street? Nothing and nothing. You write: "The Pioneer House on the other side."
On the other side of what? As you find a lot of loot on which map you pushed the closest Arabic name that could be found, Yona Street or the Prophets have no
A connection to Beit Halutz except in the fevered mind of an extreme leftist activist who must somehow tie everything to "there were Arabs there".
Revealed to Bni Zamir that you made 4 mistakes. I mentioned the first one to you. 2 - You did not at all contact the municipality for the city archives or the city museum to find out if they have any information about the pioneers' house because it does not really interest you but only using it to tease the mayor. Mistake 3 in all was bringing up a topic that everyone already wrote about a month ago. What is the circulation of an article by Doron Shafer who wrote the same things, maybe give him credit if you took and copied? 4 - And your fourth mistake is the incitement against "increased birth rate" and ultra-Orthodox values, i.e. the denial of their way of life, the opposite of any tolerance and cynical use of the building's residents to tease their sector and culture (as usual with the hypocrisy of the MRT).
There you have it, the person who made a historical distortion and created an Alak-feminist distortion in her article by maliciously using Beit Halutz is none other than the author of this article. And if the municipality dishonors the memory of Beit Halutz, in your article full of misrepresentations and wretched politicization, you sin even more against the Zionist history of Haifa and Beit Halutz (of course, Maraz as an anti-Zionist party will not talk about Zionism - and it's funny that you said that the ultra-Orthodox oppose it... and what is Maraz of today?)
Aggressive and unnecessary response! What does March matter to the description of the pioneer house? What does right and left have to do with it?
It was appropriate to use the Pioneer House as a place for women's empowerment. Don't make it a school!
There is a solution in the spirit of the city administration:
- instead of Herzl Street—— Mrs. Herzl Street
- instead of Nordau Street—–Mrs. Nordau Street.
And I suggest instead Gila to Bnei Zamir: Mr. Gil Schwafna-Anforte
Nice article. to the point Alas for the city of my past, what will we do with it..that's how we do it when the city is led by an idiot..-I wish there would be elections already so that we could get rid of it..
Accurate article! It is hard to fathom why a city's leadership would deliberately neglect its own heritage, but the fact is…