(haipo) In the Carmelia neighborhood of Haifa, a tense battle has been going on in recent days between parents of preschool-aged children and the municipal after-school care management, after a notice was received about merging the after-school care between a preschool and a compulsory kindergarten in the kindergarten cluster on the corner of Leah and Naomi streets. The parents claim that the decision was made without cooperation, without professional explanation, and without consideration for the developmental needs of the young children. As a result, they decided to shut down the after-school care and avoid sending their children until a solution is reached. The case raises broad questions about educational planning, overcrowding in after-school care, communication between the management and parents, and the gap between needs on the ground and administrative decisions.
Carmelia Garden Complex: Four Gardens in One Complex
In the center of the Carmelia neighborhood, there is a complex of four municipal kindergartens: two preschools, pre-school and pre-school (TAT + TAT) and two compulsory kindergartens. All kindergartens operate in the same physical complex, adjacent to each other, and share educational and community infrastructure. Parents say that the complex functions well with each age group receiving an appropriate response, and that in the past there have been cases where compulsory kindergartens were combined for a joint lunch, but compulsory kindergartens have never been combined with preschools.
The announcement about the unification of after-school programs at the beginning of the year
At the beginning of the school year, the after-school management informed parents that the afternoon session at Gan Tziporan (TAT) would be combined with the afternoon session at Gan Margalit (compulsory). The parents were surprised by the decision, but after a few days it was announced that the initiative would not be implemented and that the after-school sessions would be opened separately. The parents breathed a sigh of relief, understanding that the after-school management recognized the difficulty of combining 3-4 year olds with 6 year olds.
However, during the Hol HaMoed Sukkot holiday, another announcement was received about the intention to merge the after-school programs of Gan Tziporan (19 children) and Gan Margalit (10 children). The parents were surprised by the announcement, especially since it came during a vacation, without the possibility of having a proper discussion with the after-school program management and without time to prepare.

Parents' questions: Why not merge two kindergartens?
The parents asked why not merge Gan Margalit with the other compulsory kindergarten in the complex, Gan Moran, where 15 children are enrolled in the afternoon. According to them, merging the two compulsory kindergartens is logical and desirable, since these are children of the same age, with similar abilities and similar developmental needs.
The daycare management responded that the merger between Margalit and Moran was not possible due to "distance issues." This response sparked outrage among parents, as all four kindergartens are located in the same complex, just a few meters from each other. The parents noted that in the past, Moran and Margalit daycares operated in a unified manner, so this is not a precedent.
This has created a situation where, instead of merging two kindergartens for a group of 25 children, there is an intention to merge a preschool with a kindergarten for a group of 29 children, a move that parents see as a violation of the well-being of young children.
Parents are shutting down the afternoon session.
On Saturday, 03/10/2026, the parents gathered for an emergency meeting and decided to shut down the afternoon school. They announced that they would not send their children to the afternoon school on Sunday, out of genuine concern for their safety and well-being. "It is not possible for 3-year-old children to be in the afternoon school with 6-year-old children," said one of the mothers. "We contacted the after-school school administration and asked to merge the two compulsory kindergartens into one afternoon school, since the children are the same age. It makes no sense that the after-school school administration insists on merging the kindergartens and notifies us during a vacation, which made it very difficult for us to deal with things."
According to her, the parents asked for several days in which the after-school programs would continue to operate separately, to allow for an orderly conversation with the after-school program management. "We can't send the children to after-school today with kindergarten children and in two days tell the children that they are essentially returning to after-school as it was until today. Why do we have to do things in a hurry and not allow the parents to get answers?"
Lunchtime congestion: Concerns about harm to childcare
Parents emphasize that the afternoon is already a busier setting than the kindergarten itself. The teams are different, the schedule changes, and the younger children need more support. Combining a preschool with a kindergarten increases the workload and makes it harder for the staff to provide a personal response.
One of the mothers told of an incident that occurred during the camp run by the Tzaharon team on Chol HaMoed Sukkot: "My daughter is not yet 3 years old and she is weaned. Last week there were three days of camp. My daughter went to the bathroom and couldn't take her pants off and didn't get a response. This happened several times. I understand why this happens, there are many children and it's hard to reach everyone. But I don't send my daughter if she can't get the minimum conditions."
According to her, lunch was also not served on time: "I picked up my daughter at 14:30 PM and she was still without lunch, when she was supposed to get lunch as soon as she got to lunch. She was left hungry. It's not possible for a new lunch to learn things on my daughter's back."
Fear of developmental regression
Parents report that the young children are experiencing regression due to the lunch rush. "I saw her cry when I dropped her off at camp," the mother said. "She's completely weaned, she's starting to miss out. I don't want all of this to happen to my daughter. I'm not a captive audience."
Other parents say that their children come home tired, confused, and sometimes restless. They fear that combining after-school care will worsen the situation and harm the children's normal development.
Parents demand professional dialogue
The parents have scheduled another meeting for this evening (Sunday, 4/10/26), where they will decide how to continue the struggle. They claim that they hope that in the first stage the management of the daycare center will agree to suspend the unification in the coming days, to allow for a professional conversation between the parties. After that, they ask that the management of the daycare center accept their demand, not to unify pre-school children with children of compulsory age.
The parents emphasize that they are not opposed to unifying after-school programs in principle, but demand that the unification be carried out in a professional, age-appropriate manner, and in full cooperation with the parents.
Claims of lack of transparency
The parents claim that the announcement of the reunion was not communicated to them in an orderly manner at first, but rather, "we heard about it from here and there." It was not until mid-Chol HaMoed that an official announcement was sent. According to them, the lunchroom staff was also not informed in advance of the decision, which increased the sense of confusion.
"What worries us most is that after-school care is already the end of the day with other operators," said one of the mothers. "It doesn't make sense to combine another kindergarten for little ones with older children. It creates an impossible load."
Concern about safety
Other parents raised concerns about the safety of their children. "We're worried that the older children will run over the younger children," said another mother. "It's not a matter of distance between the kindergartens, it's a matter of age. Six-year-olds are stronger, faster, and sometimes less aware of children younger than them."
Demand for a long-term solution
The parents are seeking a long-term solution that will ensure that each kindergarten receives an age-appropriate afternoon care. They point out that there are enough children in the two compulsory kindergartens to combine them into one afternoon care, and that such a merger would be more logical, safe, and professional.
The response of the Tzaharon management
The management of the Tzaharon stated that they would not comment on the article.
Municipality: The decision to consolidate the after-school programs was made for safety reasons
The Haifa Municipality stated that the decision to unify the Margalit and Tziporen after-school centers was made for safety, stability, and educational continuity considerations, and out of full responsibility for the safety and well-being of the children. Three staff members will operate within the unified framework, with the kindergarten assistant who accompanies the children from morning hours also being the central figure during the afternoon hours, and the activity will take place in groups tailored to the children's ages and needs. The municipality notes that the after-school center system is in a period of organization and integration, and that the teams are closely monitoring the process in the field. Should additional needs arise, they will be given a professional and immediate response, while maintaining a safe, stable, and high-quality framework for all children.
Did the article interest you?

Haifa Municipality is a continuing failure in many areas. The residents deserve what they get for electing a mayor who was expelled a decade ago and brought back only because his replacement was poor.
City employees supported the failure and, as usual, the city's potential was never realized.
Where is the municipality?! Shame! The most expensive property taxes in the country, and our children are treated like merchandise in the supermarket!
Who is the contract manager who allowed the contractor to make such a move?
Let's unite the first and third grades, and maybe let's unite the municipality with the Shfaram municipality. Same logic.