Suspect arrested in shooting incident on Yad Labanim Road in Haifa – update

The Israel Police told Haifa: Haifa police officers arrested...

Ido Minkowski in a candid interview • The speaker who became a singer and the strategist who is not afraid to dream big

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

60 NIS compensation due to lack of accessibility at the "Cinema Cafe Amami" cinema in Haifa

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

Environmental activists challenge the felling of 21 eucalyptus trees in Kiryat Haim

(Hai Fa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) –...

The Giant from Hillel Street

Once upon a time, before the word "luxury" became a profession and before every balcony...

Where are we going from here?

Where do we go from here? To the Rose Road or the Road of the Shrouds? To the Hathatim Road or the Smiles? To the Road of the Formation or...

 Youth in Haifa during the Jewish Revolt

The period of the Hebrew rebellion between the years 1945-1946 for youth in general and for youth in Haifa...

Making Souls: Poetry, music, and creativity connect emotions and open a door to the world of those struggling with the soul.

Approximately 80 cultural, art and discourse events will be held across the country...

Angry parents: Full payment for closed dormitories during war with Iran

(haipo) For two weeks now, parents of children aged 0–3 have found themselves paying thousands of shekels for daycare, even though the daycares are completely closed and with no prospect of a return to normal. While the country is at war, many parents are dealing with a decrease in income, an increase in expenses, long days at home with children without frameworks, and at the same time being charged in full for a service that is not provided. They claim, While the Haifa Municipality and the city's community center association have chosen not to charge for after-school care, the supervised dormitories continue to charge as usual., without transparency and without a solution. The parents describe a feeling of abandonment by the state, a lack of care on the part of the authorized authorities, and a bureaucratic mechanism that leaves them helpless.

Full payment for closed dormitories: “This is unacceptable”

Many parents say that they are required to pay between 2,500 and 3,500 shekels a month for daycare, even though the daycares have been closed since the start of the fighting. They claim that while municipal kindergartens, after-school centers, and other settings in the municipality or community centers have chosen not to charge a fee, the supervised daycares continue to charge in full.

The parents point out that the ones who are supposed to report to the Ministry of Finance about the closure of the dormitories are the dormitory directors themselves, but according to them, they have no interest in rushing, because the money is already in their hands. The result: the parents continue to pay, the state does not send refunds, and the families are left to cope alone.

“I am willing to be in the police station as much as necessary — but not pay for a service that does not exist”

Ofir, a resident of Neot Peres and father of a two-year-old toddler, describes an impossible reality: “I have no complaint against my son’s kindergarten. My claim is against the municipality or the state. There can be no situation where I pay 3,000 shekels for a closed daycare. I understand the war, I understand my role on the home front, but how can they expect me not to work, to support my family, and to pay for a service that doesn’t exist?”

According to him, the feeling is of complete disconnection on the part of the decision-makers: “Do the finance officials who hold the money receive a salary? If so, why don’t they do their job? Why does the government allow itself to harm the parent community, especially in an election year? There are parents who did not receive a refund for 12 days in June, and I am supposed to subsidize the state?”

Ofir emphasizes that there are strong families that can absorb the situation, but many others are collapsing: “Young families with less financial stability are going into debt, taking out expensive credit, and their quality of life is being affected. It’s sad to see the lack of care.”

The problem is concentrated in the 0–3 age group: supervised daycare centers continue to charge

Parents explain that the problem focuses on ages 0–3, the age when children are in daycares run by WIZO, Naamat, Duvdevan and other supervised chains, or in private kindergartens. Unlike municipal settings, supervised daycares continue to charge full fees, regardless of the security situation.

Parents note that municipal kindergartens and daycare centers did not charge an advance payment, or returned the money within a few days. In contrast, the supervised daycare centers claim that they are waiting for instructions from the Ministry of Finance, while the Ministry of Finance claims that it is waiting for the reports from the daycare centers. The result is a delay that leaves parents without a solution.

“The money is already in their pockets — why should they hurry?”

Hila, a resident of Haifa and mother of three children, describes deep frustration: “The struggle belongs to everyone: supervised, private, everyone together. They didn’t charge for the after-school programs this month, not even in the schools. But the dormitories? They charged full payment in advance. The money is theirs. What interest do they have in being part of our struggle?”

Hila explains that many families are in real distress: “There are families where both spouses were put on unpaid leave. Food expenses have increased significantly because the children are at home all day. This is already a lot more days than in the previous campaign. Who is supposed to take responsibility?”

According to her, the current mechanism hurts the parents: “This system, in which the dormitory directors have to demand the money for me, is absurd. The parents are exhausted. They don’t have the strength to fight. From war to war I see how they have less strength to fight for the money, and it’s sad.”

Private kindergartens: different contracts, different realities

In private kindergartens, the situation is more complex. Each kindergarten operates under a different contract with the parents. There are kindergartens where it is determined in advance that the payment is annual and fixed, even if the kindergarten is closed. In such cases, it is difficult to demand a refund. In other kindergartens, the kindergarten owners choose to refund part of the payment or offer solutions such as Zoom meetings.

However, even private kindergarten owners face fixed expenses: rent, property taxes, insurance, which cannot be stopped even when the kindergarten is closed. Therefore, some have difficulty repaying money to parents.

“The Haifa Municipality and the community centers have proven that it is possible otherwise”

Many parents praise the Haifa Municipality and the Neve Yosef Community Center, which operates the after-school programs in the city, for returning funds for after-school programs within a few days in the previous campaign. They claim that this proves that it is possible to act quickly and transparently, if you just want to.

Hila explains: “The lunches cost 1,000 shekels per month per child, much less than the dorms. And yet, the municipality returned the money immediately. That’s the difference in how things are conducted. When there’s a will, there’s a solution.”

Parents collapse: “We no longer have the strength”

Beyond the financial burden, parents describe a heavy mental burden: long days at home with small children, alarms, lack of routine, lack of support, and all this while they are required to continue paying for frameworks that are not working.

“The parents are submissive,” says Hila. “They have no strength. They are exhausted by the security situation, the alarms, the days without frameworks. They are unable to fight for the money they deserve.” Currently, the Ministry of Finance claims that it is waiting for the reports from the dormitories to examine refunds. The dormitories claim that they are waiting for instructions from the Ministry of Finance. The parents feel that they are falling through the cracks, with no one willing to take responsibility.

Ministry of Finance response: “Refunds will be included in the compensation outline”

The Ministry of Finance stated that last week a compensation plan for businesses for loss of income during Operation "Roar of the Lion" was published, and that private kindergartens and daycare centers are considered, for all intents and purposes, private businesses eligible for compensation. The ministry clarified that refunding payments to parents for services not provided is considered part of the business owner's loss of income, and therefore he will be able to receive compensation in accordance with the rules set out in the plan. It also noted that in previous systems, the state transferred payments quickly and efficiently, and that the Knesset is expected to approve the plan in legislation in the coming days.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the newsroom: At watsap • By email

Michal Grover
Michal Grover
Michal Grover Education reporter • Real estate • Company Contact: 054-4423911 Mail to the container: [email protected]

Articles related to this topic

2 תגובות

  1. The parents are absolutely right. They don't receive service, so why pay for something they don't receive?? Crazy!

  2. You missed the point that we are waiting for representatives of the Ministry of Labor to give us compensation that was not given for the previous campaign against Iran.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Over 300 people at the annual event of Yad Labanim Haifa

(Hai Pa) – Over 300 people participated in the annual event of the Yad Labanim Haifa House, which was held at the Garden Hotel in Haifa. The event was attended by bereaved families from every district...

Change in food labeling in Israel: This is how you will identify allergens and avoid mistakes when buying

(Hai Pa - Haifa and Surrounding Area News Corporation) – Before you put a product in your shopping cart, it's worth taking a few seconds to read the label on the packaging. List...

Robbed an 80-year-old woman, knocked her down and injured her • 4 years in prison for Alexander Maruga

(Live News Corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - The Haifa District Court sentenced Alexander Maruga to 48 months in prison, who was convicted of robbing an elderly woman...

A pedestrian was hit by a vehicle on the Acre-Haifa road and was taken to the Rambam Hospital in serious condition.

(Hai Pa - Haifa News Corporation) – A 40-year-old pedestrian was hit by a vehicle this afternoon on the Acre-Haifa road, in Kiryat Bialik, and was taken to a hospital in serious condition...

General Clinic in Bat Galim Expands Pediatric Services – A Solution Close to Home

Good news for young families in the Bat Galim neighborhood in Haifa: Clalit has expanded pediatric services at the neighborhood clinic, with the addition of a specialist pediatrician to the team. The move is intended...