(haipo) – About two years ago, as you may recall, a retaining wall on Yad Labanim Road in Haifa suddenly collapsed, with only a miracle preventing a disaster and no casualties. Residents of the street fear that the sad history could repeat itself, and warn that the continuation of the wall is showing clear signs of weakness, including significant cracks and noticeable shifts, and could collapse at any moment.
Yehuda Dahan, a resident of the street, says that he has repeatedly warned the municipality about the real danger posed by the state of the dilapidated sidewalk and wall, but he says that the institutions have remained deaf. "We are talking about a very dangerous safety hazard. If the wall collapses, it could lead to a major disaster - and there is no progress in addressing the problem," Dahan says angrily.
The situation on Yad Labanim Road is particularly worrying given the fact that it is one of the city's main thoroughfares, with heavy vehicle and pedestrian traffic. Despite the obvious danger, and despite past experience, it appears that no preventive measures are being taken to stop the possibility of another collapse.
Are we waiting for a disaster? And what will it take for the responsible authorities to take the warnings seriously? For now, the answers remain a mystery, and residents are forced to live in the shadow of fear of a possible collapse that would put lives at risk.
Dahan shares his difficult feelings: "We feel abandoned, as if we are second-class residents. If a similar situation were to occur in a neighborhood in Carmel, things would look different. For two years we have been warning about the danger. An engineer who visited the site confirmed to me that this is a dangerous situation and that the wall could collapse at any moment. How long will we have to fight to be taken care of? We also pay property taxes, we are law-abiding citizens – it is time for the municipality to take care of us."
No response was given from the Haifa municipality.
◄ An interview conducted with Dahan in the field, April 2023, already warned of the danger at that time • It seems that the situation is now even more serious and poses a real danger • Watch
Did the article interest you?


For anyone who jumps in here too – we need to distinguish between walls inside private lots and public walls.
A residential building that has a stone fence that collapses into the street, the tenants have to finance the renovation. The municipality can perhaps help with a designated budget through the Shikmona company or Yaffe Nof – a building assistance fund to repair retaining walls and fences. But this is not a hazard of the municipality, it is a hazard of private property that the building owners are obligated to repair. They don’t have to – they are obligated. Because if such a wall collapses on a pedestrian on the sidewalk, God forbid, they will also be held liable in a tort claim for negligence in the management of the building. The same goes for buildings with cracked columns or cracked ceilings that the building inspector ignores or does cosmetic work on.
The House Committee is exposed to personal lawsuits if it fails to take action over the years, knowing that there is damage that requires repair.
It's better to stop blaming the municipality and rolling your eyes. Those who own property should take care of their property.
All the warning bells are ringing loudly – the section of the wall that has already collapsed and also the wide crack visible in the retaining wall in the photo.
It's a matter of time before the retaining wall on Yad Labanim Road collapses again.
There is no dispute that the retaining wall in its current condition poses a real danger to users of this road and its vicinity.
There is a serious fundamental problem there that was revealed after the collapse of the wall section - we are dealing with serious structural deficiencies - whether in the design of the retaining wall, whether in the design of the subgrade layers under the roadway, whether in the design of the drainage system in this area, whether in poor execution of all of the above, or in a fatal combination of poor design along with poor execution of all of the parameters mentioned above.
Already in the findings discovered in the fill layers after the wall collapsed, it was possible to diagnose serious defects in the fill soil and the substrate layers beneath the asphalt layer.
It is very likely that this entire road was built using the same faulty "method", and therefore there is a high chance that another collapse of the retaining wall along with the road will soon occur.
To the extent that the municipality does not take operative steps to prevent the possible disaster, all residents of the nearby houses must organize to file an urgent lawsuit against the municipality with a demand for immediate repair of the entire defective infrastructure system in the dangerous area.
Clearly, plugging the crack is not the solution required, and is even worse than sticking a Band-Aid on a contaminated wound.
Why talk nonsense? When you build a wall properly, it should hold the filling. The problem was with the wall, not the filling.
Haifa Municipality: It's time to wake up and not abandon the residents of Haifa. We ask that you please repair the crack in the wall that the residents of Haifa noticed.
The main problem is that there is no personal responsibility for those responsible in the municipality for implementation.
The Haifa Municipality has not functioned as a responsible local authority for years.
All actions are patchwork.
Roads, cleaning, retaining walls, potholes and potholes, street lighting, pruning vegetation that interferes with sidewalks and vegetation that hides crosswalks, and more….
Why don't you hurry up and ask questions? Have a lovely day.
Dear Yehuda, I am not writing this comment to discourage you. I recommend that you continue to appeal and press until you achieve the result that reality demands. I just wanted you to know that you are not alone, there are other citizens working to correct the serious injustices of the Haifa Municipality, at least some of them – it does not always help – usually it does not help. The reason for the collapse of the functioning of the Haifa Municipality is that the officials, especially the senior ones, and not all of them, but the most prominent and influential of them, as well as the elected representatives elected to the City Council (hereinafter – the rule of corrupt officials), do not do their job faithfully, they worship other things, except for performing their duties, that is how it is with the vast majority of them, you can always find one righteous person in Sodom, I have not found one yet, but I continue to search. They simply do not do what is entrusted to them faithfully, and it is all lawlessness and dysfunction – and only the pockets of the corrupt are filled all the way to the bank.
Why aren't inquiries being addressed? Maybe because people don't approach in the usual way? Maybe you need to know someone or hire a lot of money to hire some kind of adjudicator? Maybe you need to pay a lot of money or is it all one big mistake and you need to be patient until, God forbid, someone gets hurt, for example, dies, then maybe some senior, well-heeled official will move his name from its usual place and do something.