Suspect arrested in shooting incident on Yad Labanim Road in Haifa – update

The Israel Police told Haifa: Haifa police officers arrested...

Ido Minkowski in a candid interview • The speaker who became a singer and the strategist who is not afraid to dream big

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

60 NIS compensation due to lack of accessibility at the "Cinema Cafe Amami" cinema in Haifa

(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - After...

Environmental activists challenge the felling of 21 eucalyptus trees in Kiryat Haim

(Hai Fa - Haifa and the surrounding area news corporation) –...

The Giant from Hillel Street

Once upon a time, before the word "luxury" became a profession and before every balcony...

Where are we going from here?

Where do we go from here? To the Rose Road or the Road of the Shrouds? To the Hathatim Road or the Smiles? To the Road of the Formation or...

 Youth in Haifa during the Jewish Revolt

The period of the Hebrew rebellion between the years 1945-1946 for youth in general and for youth in Haifa...

Making Souls: Poetry, music, and creativity connect emotions and open a door to the world of those struggling with the soul.

Approximately 80 cultural, art and discourse events will be held across the country...

The "Pioneer Street" affair: Attorney Sharit Golan will overturn the strange decision from Kalish's tenure as chairman of the Names Committee

This morning, Monday, 17/1/22, there was severe criticism of the strange decision made by the Municipal Names Committee, headed by Dr. Einat Kalish-Rotem, to change the name of half of Halutz Street in Haifa to Halutz Street. The criticism which was written by Prof. Yossi Ben Artzi, who was previously the chairman of the Names Committee, was published in Hai Fe.

A few weeks ago, the Change Council removed Kalish from the chairmanship of the committee and appointed attorney Sharit Golan. This made it possible to correct the problem.

Attorney Sharit Golan, the chairperson of the incoming committee, appointed by the Change Council and replacing Kalish, told Lahi Fe:

Attorney Sharit Golan
Attorney Sharit Golan

I would like to immediately check the possibility of freezing the decision of the city council which approved the name change for half of Halutz Street to Halutz.

This is about adopting the decision of the Names Committee in its previous composition headed by Mayor Einat Kalish. It seems that the committee in its previous composition fell into a mistake when it believed that Halutz Street speaks with a general word for a pioneer and therefore sought to empower women and name its part as Halutz Street, but it is a street named after the "Halutz" movement.

In any case, changing the name of a street, part or all of it, as opposed to giving a new name, should be done in a different legal way, so it should be discussed anew.

The news column of Prof. Yossi Ben Artzi, and is an important part of the reviews that have reached me in recent days.

The story illustrates the urgent need to appoint a professional to accompany the committee and prepare the materials for it. 

Dr. Or Barak, member of the city council and acting chairman of the Municipal Names Committee, told Lahi Fe:

Council member Dr. Or Barak. (Photo: Paparazzi Dodi)

What appears to be an attempt to present Haifa at the forefront of the Enlightenment turned Haifa into a provincial joke. While through a public and/or political lens, this type of decision can be interpreted as a mistake that needs to be settled, through a professional lens it is an embarrassing mistake that has many consequences, since street names do not just "indicate a place in space". They are interconnected in a dynamic fabric that weaves the cultural geography of the urban space.

Granting names to streets "as an arbitrary procedural matter" and without understanding the cultural meanings that stand behind such grants, are no less than destroying the design of identity and urban heritage.

This position is joined by my professional colleagues, a series of professors from academic institutions throughout the country, which is their area of ​​expertise. Like them, I, too, find it difficult to contain the feeling of frustration that decisions of this type arouse in me.

I was privileged to have the supervisor of my doctoral thesis none other than Prof. Maoz Azarihu, a cultural geographer whose field of expertise is street names in the urban space. For those who want to expand their knowledge in the field, I would be happy to refer to his books, among them: Tel Aviv: The (A) Mythical City (Sde Booker 2005); Named after: History and Politics of Street Names in Israel (Jerusalem 2012); At their death they ordered: the architecture of the military cemeteries (Tel Aviv 2012); Positioning the memory (Haifa 2018). For an extension to international cases and not just national ones, I can also refer to his books in English, which focus on establishing streets in other countries.

As a matter of fact, I would like to join the request of the chairman of the committee to find a way to immediately cancel this embarrassing decision.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the newsroom: At watsap • By email

Noga Carmi
Noga Carmi
Nega Karmi - Director of Haifa News Corporation - News of Haifa and the surrounding area - message on WhatsApp: 052-2410689 Sending an email to the system: [email protected]

Articles related to this topic

25 תגובות

  1. Gentlemen, if the person jumping at the head of the municipality would have checked before jumping headfirst into another empty pool... probably like in Zichron Ya'akov in the permit issue... like in the barbecue area in Benue David... like in the closing of the holidays... like in the benches without a permit in Nahal Saadia...
    The lady jumps in and only then checks or gets hit hard at the bottom of the pool.
    Hashomer street named after the Hashomer organization.
    Halutz street named after the Halutz organization.
    But how can you expect those who lack a minimal Zionist and settlement education to know what this is all about?
    How can you expect a kiosk owner with tax entanglements and convictions to be a thorough person who can run a naming committee? Do not expect.
    Don't expect anything. Only scandals and failures. with or without accompanying stigma.

  2. Finally someone from the outside will put an end to this cliché clown.
    There is heritage, and there is history, and there are Haifaites who grew up on this history and it cannot come from someone who, through the machinations of the Combine, was elected mayor of the most delusional and most destructive city that the city of Haifa has had to date.
    That there will also be an urgent decision to impeach and hold early elections

  3. And what about HaShomer Street located in the Yaya area, if it was called HaShomer Street that differentiated between the Arab and Jewish neighborhoods in the 1930s, it got its name and its name should not be changed to "Hashomerat" street since over the years there was not actually any female guard that guarded this street

  4. You need to find some dark alley and call it "Psycho Alley" and then the cliché will have no doubt that they took care of both the female gender and immortalizing a chosen lucky person

  5. This cliché woman has a problem with herself. She wanted to give and glorify the Halutz Street, which is actually the Khalutz movement, but I remember the Halutz Street. without movement. And why half of the street to the pioneer is really a joke. Proves how she does things without tact. That you name another street after one of the pioneers
    She only wanted to raise and increase the pioneers who were true, there were quite a few. By the way my grandmother was one of them. But why half a block? Sounds very funny

  6. More name suggestions:
    Called Committee Street
    that probably only she will save us from the leadership or lack of leadership of the delusional municipality.
    Hugi Beit St
    In which a cliche overflows promises in every field and the opposite works. Let us remember not to believe promises and to demand proven experience in managing a large organization from any future mayor.
    Free Press Street
    This is a street that Eliran Tal the speaker will be able to remember when he passes by, what is the role of the media in his attempts to financially stifle advertising on them every ten days

  7. First clean this street, and rehabilitate it from all the garbage that is there before you try to do cheap marketing tricks on us

  8. Thank God!!
    I pray that the hallucinatory decisions stop / will stop.
    It is enough for us that we have become a joke in the whole country, regarding the title - "City of Pigs"
    Now the unfortunate name change of Halutz St.
    When will the dance of fools stop in the municipality?
    I hope that with the replacement of the Chairman of the Rehovot Names Committee - the order will be restored?

  9. Kalman, I think they will become a savior if at all (will they add desire???) ha ha

  10. Striker or guard expresses occupation and not gender
    Enough to castrate the Hebrew

  11. It's a shame, I was hoping that the striker and the striker would meet in the middle and then we would have small strikers

  12. I also say to you Sarit and Or,
    In Haifa, there is no street named after Yitzhak Rabin where people live, with the exception of the Government Kiryat in the lower city, which no one calls Kiryat Rabin but the Government Kiryat, if at all.
    Immediately after Rabin's murder, I suggested to Yossi Ben-Artzi that International Street be named after him "Maale Akoum" and he rejected my suggestion!
    There is no street like this in any city in Israel, and no one will be offended by the change of this long and cumbersome name, which many always find difficult and disrupt the pronunciation.
    In our country, there are no street names from the period of the Communist International Anthem that deserve to be removed from Haifa.
    Rabin Street is worthy in our Haifa, just like Ramot Alon, Eshkol, Begin, Golda, Remez, Sapir and many other good names!!!
    Sarit and Or, let's get to the important work: Rabin Main Street is long and wide, as befits Rabbi Yitzhak Rabin who worked in the State of Israel until his terrible murder!

  13. Until the moment I heard about it, I doubted whether Mayor Kalish had any sense.
    This news answered my question.

  14. On the same occasion, also Rehov
    The pioneers of the industry for the pioneers of the industry

  15. Amazing, simply unbelievable, Rehov Hashomer will become a Shumer. The Dakar submarine - it would have to be the submarine. where is the stop HaGilil Street will be transformed into a scroll?
    That I understand, there is really nothing to fix / do in Haifa that is what is needed? The streets named after female singers - how do they also translate to male?
    Unbelievable, simply unbelievable.
    I very much hope that the voice of reason will come from Attorney Sharit Golan.
    Despite being a woman - there is a limit

    • The name of Herzl Street must be changed immediately to Mrs. Herzl Street.
      But the culprits are the city's residents, because they are the ones who chose the current city administration.
      They must spend a minute, before putting a note in the ballot box.

  16. hahahahahahahaha
    After all, Mrs. Golan claims that they did a thorough job in rebroadcasting the Names Committee on 12.12.2021 when they went over the sections approved on 02.08.21 and the pioneers section she and the committee chaired approved.
    Waiver of this, the committee headed by Golan brought the clause to the council for approval and the council approved.
    As much as they did examine the matters in depth, they should have discovered the mistake they are claiming.
    This only proves that the cancellation of Wad al-Jamal-Ain al-Hayam was also done in the blink of an eye without a thorough examination.
    shame

    • To what levels of nonsense and mistakes does Mrs. Klish fall.
      The problem is that it goes easily to her.
      Instead of dealing with obtaining development budgets, the lady deals with turning streets into couples and kinds of trifles and vanities....
      That's how it is when you choose Curiosity for mayor of a city in Israel.

    • This cliché woman has a problem with herself. She wanted to give and glorify the Halutz Street, which is actually the Khalutz movement, but I remember the Halutz Street. without movement. And why half of the street to the pioneer is really a joke. Proves how she does things without tact. That you name another street after one of the pioneers
      She only wanted to raise and increase the pioneers who were true, there were quite a few. By the way my grandmother was one of them. But why half a block? Sounds very funny

    • Mrs. Pagoa the street that was changed back to a Jewish street. He won't return to the street to get out, because then it was during the mandate period, today it is the Jewish state. Then they changed streets to Hebrew, so it's not funny. Because the name will remain a Hebrew name. We will update you. There was pressure from the Jews to change what was during the mandate period. Nice .
      .

The article is closed for comments. You can share online using the share buttons

All the articles are alive

Over 300 people at the annual event of Yad Labanim Haifa

(Hai Pa) – Over 300 people participated in the annual event of the Yad Labanim Haifa House, which was held at the Garden Hotel in Haifa. The event was attended by bereaved families from every district...

Change in food labeling in Israel: This is how you will identify allergens and avoid mistakes when buying

(Hai Pa - Haifa and Surrounding Area News Corporation) – Before you put a product in your shopping cart, it's worth taking a few seconds to read the label on the packaging. List...

Robbed an 80-year-old woman, knocked her down and injured her • 4 years in prison for Alexander Maruga

(Live News Corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) - The Haifa District Court sentenced Alexander Maruga to 48 months in prison, who was convicted of robbing an elderly woman...

A pedestrian was hit by a vehicle on the Acre-Haifa road and was taken to the Rambam Hospital in serious condition.

(Hai Pa - Haifa News Corporation) – A 40-year-old pedestrian was hit by a vehicle this afternoon on the Acre-Haifa road, in Kiryat Bialik, and was taken to a hospital in serious condition...

General Clinic in Bat Galim Expands Pediatric Services – A Solution Close to Home

Good news for young families in the Bat Galim neighborhood in Haifa: Clalit has expanded pediatric services at the neighborhood clinic, with the addition of a specialist pediatrician to the team. The move is intended...