Ein Hayam neighborhood or Wadi Jamal neighborhood? The Naming Committee of the Haifa Municipality made a controversial recommendation
The names committee of the Haifa municipality recommended adding the name Wadi Jamal to the name of the neighborhood Ein Hayam. According to the protocol of the committee meeting, the original Arabic name of the neighborhood from the 30s will be added to the official name of the neighborhood and therefore it will be called Ein Hayam - Wadi Jamal.
It should be noted that the committee's recommendations are a recommendation only, and the city council must approve the recommendation in order for it to become a decision.
Padua Srouji, a resident of the neighborhood and a social activist who was happy about the recommendation, told Lahi Pa:
I have been working for many years for the registration of the Arabic neighborhood name "Wadi El Jamal" alongside the Hebrew neighborhood name "Ein Hayam". This is the original name of the neighborhood that was built in the late 20s and without a doubt it is a neighborhood of good neighborliness among all its residents. The name of the Arab neighborhood is a historical name and not only that, that is, it is a name that lives in the mouths of the residents of the neighborhood and residents outside it, whether Arabs or Jews, so the importance of listing the two names side by side on the official signage of the neighborhood and in general officially in the various institutions is an essential and desirable matter. I thank all the members of the Names Committee and Mayor Einat Kalish, and especially I thank all the hundreds of signatories on a petition I distributed in support of this matter.

Not everyone liked the decision and its opponents have already arisen, including Eli Debi. Debi is the founder of an organization of bereaved brothers called "Lancetsah Ahi", the chairman of the rehabilitation committee of the Yad Labanim organization and an activist in the neighborhood where he grew up.
Eli Debi gave me a message here:
My late brother Zadok grew up in the Ein Hayam neighborhood and was killed in 1978 for defending the state and the Ein Hayam neighborhood and not Wadi Jamal. The Arab residents of the neighborhood also want to keep the name of the neighborhood "Ein Hayam" and are not opposed to the Jewish character. There is a Torah yeshiva named after Zadok which is in the neighborhood. In 2006, the municipality determined that the name of the neighborhood will forever be only "Ein Hayam" and not "Wadi Jamal". The neighborhood is going to be the pearl of the city and pass TMA 38. Instead of moving forward, there are a number of Arabs who want to go backwards. We won't let that happen. We will fight in our body to request to change the name of the neighborhood, either through petitions or through demonstrations, Jews and Arabs together.

Yoav Ramati, a member of the city council from the Jewish Home faction, also expressed his displeasure with the proposal
Yoav Ramati sent a message to Hai Pa:
I oppose the name change since the city is not involved just as the state is not involved. The city is Jewish with a population from different sectors. Just as in the world the country is Israel and the city is Haifa, so the neighborhood is Ein Haim and no other.
Another point: how far do we go back to the first person? 1800 years ago, the aforementioned Rabbi Abdimi Daman lived in the lower city of Haifa. At that time the city was called Haifa. Therefore there is no room to change the name of the Ein Hayam neighborhood.

The municipality chose not to respond.
Did the article interest you?

As a native of the neighborhood who grew up as a child next to the Arab neighbors until the age of 4, and as a native of Beit Hochuim Moheda Laim Rambam, I welcome the addition of the Arab name in the previous Wadi Jamel which does not offend the Jewish character and only adds
interesting !!! Is there coexistence in Haifa or is it an illusion???????????????
I am glad that we are fighting for the restoration of God to me. Whoever it is. The one in whose name the Jew was murdered can be named after him. All the murdered should be commemorated because I suffered for nothing, no one cares about them who were active for Haifa. My grandmother was in the defense and was murdered. She was active and supported the neighborhood. Neighbors probably knew and that's why the Arab neighbor murdered her. By the way, Vadi G, a mill named after a river in Syria from 1820. Why did they change the name here, what is ours and to a name that does not belong to our past.
In my opinion, the change of names is accompanied by a relative change in the composition of the population in the city of Haifa. There is no arguing that the status quo has been maintained for the time being, but the city is losing its Jewish character and, unfortunately, its democratic character at an alarming rate. The problem of violence and unrest increases because of the younger generation, which does not know the environmental economic and political situation, and appears militant and wild. The problem of violence from the surrounding villages permeates Haifa, and we will have to get used to it.
I propose to call the Ein Hayam neighborhood "Wadi Behar" Behar in Arabic means sea and in Hebrew it is the root of the word Behar
The Jews founded the whole country on "going back" until when do we go back only when the Jews rest???
Most of the Ein Hayam neighborhood is inhabited by Arabs, now with the changing of the name of the neighborhood to an Arab name, the neighborhood is completely handed over to the Arabs. What remains is to annex it to the Palestinian Authority and then Haifa as a whole... All respect, and no respect, to Mrs. Kalish and her people.
Wadi Jamal? May the fanatics die
How about Stanton Street or Kings Road. Suitable for Haifa to go back.
Give Arab names in Jordan, it is not at all interesting how the conquering Arabs called the country before the establishment of the country under the auspices of the Ottomans. Names must be verified. Hebrews for settlement and neighborhood. There is no place for names that are not in Hebrew in the Land of Israel. It has nothing to do with brotherhood and neighborliness. We live in the Jewish state.
The next step is to add Bald al-Sheikh to Nesher Hill, the name of the tomb of the Arab hero Ezzedine al-Qassem.
With all due respect to the good neighbor, it is worth thinking about whether apartment prices will be affected by such a change.
It is not in the interest of any of the sectors that live deliberately to harm themselves.
Inappropriate! Tomorrow the Arabs of the place will decide that it suits them to lie to the place of Wadi Arafat! There is no place to change Jewish neighborhoods to Arab names.
1948 is dead, we are not going back, we are in a new era.
Shame on the municipality for such a recommendation. Yes, I grew up in the neighborhood for 30 years. We fought and were hurt for the sake of the existence of the country and not for the sake of both consciousness and the names. We will fight against this to the end. Because someone ran and already changed the name of the neighborhood.
Stop living in fear, as if every day the Holocaust is going to return, God forbid, and more in the Land of Israel. The State of Israel is strong enough to allow us to live together with the Arab minority and respect their heritage as well, without any fear. The Arabs of Israel know that this is a strong and established Jewish and democratic state. They also know that it is much better for them in Israel than for the Arabs who live in our neighboring countries or under the Palestinian Authority and of course under the rule of Hamas in Gaza. The name Wadi Hemelim (in western translation) is a beautiful name and should not cause any nationalistic problem. At least the name of the neighborhood known today is Ein Haim and will remain so.
Adding the name Wadi Jamal to Ein Haim is illegal!!! Its approval may set a precedent for adding the name Palestine to Israel. Avoid the disgrace at all costs. If the lady wants to live in a place with an Arab name, there are no such friends in the Galilee. In fact, it might be better in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, etc. Reject the offer!!!
There is Wadi Jamel in Jordan, Syria and Iraq - that's enough in Israel, Ein Hayam!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
If it was a question of canceling the new name and restoring the historical Arab name, there would be reason to object. But it is only about mentioning the old name and through it mentioning the historical dimension of the neighborhood, it is definitely a welcome step. To learn and know is not an injury but a blessing. In my opinion, the curriculum of students in Haifa Roers should include a choice about the history of the special city Hazen.