Discussion on the issue of children's rights:
"The model for my learning was the city of Haifa," said MK Yifat Biton Shasha, chairman of the Child Rights Committee, at a meeting held with directors and supervisors of the education system in Haifa.
MK Yifat Biton Shasha from the "Kulana" party arrived on Tuesday 13.09.16 visited the Haifa Municipality, for an open meeting in the executive hall of the Haifa Municipality.

Yifat's connection to the education system:
MK Yifat Biton Shasha testifies to her special connection to the issue of education in the city of Kiryat Shmona.
She says: "I entered the world of education at the age of 20, I acquired my education at the University of Haifa with a bachelor's, master's and master's degree in education. I was a teacher, educator and subject coordinator and vice president of Ohalo College in Katsrin.
I have not had time to run a school yet, I am interested in realizing this task after I complete tasks in the Knesset.

In Kiryat Shmona I was the deputy mayor. I insisted on holding both the education portfolio, the youth portfolio and the welfare portfolio. I wanted to hold all the issues to address the entire avenue of issues related to education.
Building the connection between the different systems was not easy for me... the connection between the social worker and the educator was not obvious. I wanted to build a new language in the urban reality.
To my surprise I discovered that within the education system itself there was no common language.
Yifat also says that Kiryat Shmona is an aging city and the education system suffers from a lack of budget.
With such budgets it is difficult to implement far-reaching plans at the school level.
When I held the position of deputy mayor and holder of the education portfolio in the city of Kiryat Shmona, I contacted Ilana Truk in order to learn from her rich professional experience in the city of Haifa. I saw that a critical mass of students and budgets was required, so I wanted to try and unite schools and thus create a school that has enough mass to lead change.
A common language between education and welfare: In the end, we managed to create a common language between the schools in the city, for example, a common science program for the schools. We created working groups. We created a learning city. We coordinated tests that were submitted simultaneously to all schools. I recruited the welfare people and we created a work team which began to talk and carry out mutual fertilization and coordination between the welfare systems, education and informal education. This momentum continued even after I left the system and my transition to the Knesset.
We tried to make the teaching staff aware that the children should receive a complete service, even after school hours.
The dialogue between the systems is an important dialogue: We also created a connection between the formal education and the informal systems, that is, the youth movements, which we brought into the schools. Kiryat Shmona developed into a learning city and we created conversation circles. Dialogue between the systems is also essential for the protection of the child's well-being. An optimal system, of transferring information between education and welfare, may identify parents who are mentally ill and save children from dangerous situations, but there are limitations of legality due to the confidentiality of the information.
Therefore, I am now submitting a bill that will allow better coordination between the systems and a clear definition of situations in which it is permissible to transfer information between the various bodies entrusted with child welfare, without fear of breaking the law, when details are transferred between the bodies. We will do everything necessary to save children in risky situations, added Shasha.
Discussion on the issue of children's rights
Dorit Bar David, social worker: When we intervene in the issues of child welfare in the family, to the extent that we make an ethical mistake, we need the backing of public representatives. We feel that we do not have enough backing from the politicians.

Yifat Biton Shasha replies:
I received many inquiries about social workers who supposedly "kidnapped children from their homes"...
Instead of blaming the employees, I came to the system to explain to what extent it is sometimes about saving lives.
The most difficult cases are when a child must be saved from his parents.
The decision to take a child out of the home is a very difficult decision.
I was faced with a story of a father who wanted to sell his daughter. The court ruled that the girl should be returned to her parents. I went against the decision and today I pray for the peace of the girl, adds Shasha.
Education is not a sterile field
We are required to make difficult decisions. Only in retrospect can we know if we made the right decisions.
That is why the system must support the educators.
Parents should be partners, but cannot take the role of administrators of the education system.
Principal of Haifa "Urban III" High School - Yehoshua ben Itamar: The parents' council is an institution that started with the desire to establish a good relationship between the parents. But, in the absence of a regulation regarding the selection of the parents' council, a situation has arisen in which anyone can head it, even people with a criminal background.
The Child Rights Law was recently enacted. Establish regulations regarding the permanent expulsion of a student. The school principal is not a member of this committee.
Recently there is a policy according to which there are almost no conditions that allow a student to be expelled, neither regarding academic achievements nor in the aspect of school attendance.
In Haifa, a move was made to prevent dropouts, which is unusual in Israel. This move reduced the dropout rate from 30 percent to just over 2 percent, said Ben Itamar.

Ilan Vakinin, director of Kiryat Haim High School: The media has recently intervened strongly. I would like to point out positively that the appointed levels return the power to decide specifically to the school. This is positive and important
In the weak families we often encounter a lack of parental authority.
There we must intervene and try to keep these children in the frame, until service in the army.

Yiffit, the principal of Urban School A, asked MK Shasha: How did the education revolution affect the negative immigration in Kiryat Shmona?
Yifat Biton Shasha replies: In the past, many children went to study in kibbutzim. Today this trend has changed. Today, more children stay to study in the city.
Today there is a negative migration of young people after the army from Kiryat Shmona, but this is also a result of the fact that those who were good students, tend to go to strong areas in their adulthood, because they have the option of choosing.
Discussion on the issue of dropping out of private schools
Hai's question here, regarding private schools that drop weak students (it was important for me to know what the regulator defines regarding this...)
Ilana Truk The Director of the Education Department in the Haifa Municipality responds: According to the Nahari Law, the schools that declare the selection and intentional dropout of students who do not meet the school's threshold requirements, receive 65 percent funding from the Ministry of Education. The Reali school in Haifa is like that.
Schools that do not drop out, get 75 percent, for example Leo-Bak.
In the case of intentional dropout, the student has the right to appeal 14 days from the expulsion notice, even in private schools.

Discussion regarding suicidal tendencies
In recent years, the age at which children talk about suicidal tendencies has been decreasing. Already in grades 3-4, teachers are exposed to hints of this and that from children at school.
The phenomenon is apparently caused by the exposure of young children to difficult programs on the Internet and on television.
The inspectors present in the room addressed the issue and replied that there is a CEO's circular that addresses this issue and presents a clear procedure:
Inform parents, take the child for diagnosis, consult with the educational consultant.
Rivi, school psychologist: The school psychologist should meet with the child.
In the initial period, the child is watched over and the level of risk is assessed.

bereaved brothers
Eli Debi, Chairman of the association "Forever Achi" which deals with the care of bereaved siblings: A bereaved sibling at school is not identified and is not accompanied. The child admitted to the school does not usually inform about the fact that there is an employee in the family. As a result, a variety of behavioral problems may arise as a result of the bereavement in the family, are not identified by the school faculty. In accordance with our demand, this year's CEO's circular contains for the first time the explanation regarding the unique treatment of bereaved siblings at the school.
Member of Knesset Yifat Biton Shasha added to Eli Debi's words: We are testing the option of including the loss in the standard health declaration form at the school, as an optional field, in order to allow the child to inform the educational staff about the loss in the family.

Reference to private lessons:
System question live here:
Are teachers allowed to recommend that children who have difficulty with the study material take tutoring in settings outside of school?
Lahi Pa learned that such a phenomenon is indeed rare, but reports are received about it from various schools in the city.
What is the position of the regulator on this matter and should parents bear the burden of private instruction when their child has difficulty with the material?
MK Yifat Biton Shasha refers to complementary frameworks within the walls of the school: I am bothered by bodies that enter schools in the afternoon and complete their studies, because then gaps are created in the morning. The teachers focus their effort and attendance specifically in the afternoon, because then they receive extras in the framework of Oz in return.
Today, teachers receive additional payment for activities after school hours, but school administrators must make sure that this activity does not harm the motivation of the teaching staff in the morning hours.
And what about the referral to frameworks outside the school (we make it difficult with questions):
MK Yifat Biton Shasha replies:
The teacher must not refer students to a private setting to keep up with the class.
Ilana Truk responds on the issue of referral to private tutoring:
Such cases, if reported in the education system in Haifa, will be dealt with severely.
Parents, for your information... if you have encountered the phenomenon of a teacher referring students to private settings, know that this is a prohibited phenomenon.

