Meshulam House – Modernism Hidden from View

At 7 Hanadiv Blvd., in the heart of the Shambor neighborhood on the Carmel, behind...

History in Haifa: About 10,000 runners participated in the first Haifa International Marathon

(Live here) – The first Haifa International Marathon arrived this morning...

Second-hand: The trend that gives clothes new life

Between the changing collections and the trends that demand space in the wardrobe,...

The struggle over the Aliyah school: Parents ran in protest at the Haifa Marathon

(Live here) – The first Haifa Marathon, held today (Friday,...

Flower of the week • Shooting star

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column we will represent...

Cafe-Tzur in Acre • A period when the north of the country competed bravely against the center

A young, sturdy redhead, fluent in Arabic, succeeded during the austerity period...

On Life From the Heart • A Home Afternoon

She is a friend of 45 years, announces that she will come to the house lunch. A gathering...

Flower of the week • Shooting star

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column we will represent...

Meshulam House – Modernism Hidden from View

At 7 Hanadiv Blvd., in the heart of the Shambor neighborhood on the Carmel, behind...

Second-hand: The trend that gives clothes new life

Between the changing collections and the trends that demand space in the wardrobe,...

66 fingers, one government on the way? Lieberman trains the Haredim, Segalovich trains the Ra'am | Opinion column

The election of Matan Kahane as Knesset Speaker is more than a parliamentary achievement for the Change Bloc. It is a signal of a shift in the balance of power and a demonstration of how agreements between rivals may shape the next government. However, between garnering a majority in the plenum and establishing a stable coalition, there are still conflicting interests, commitments to voters, and heavy political costs.

The election of MK Matan Kahane as Knesset Speaker, with a majority of 66 supporters against 52 opponents, is not merely a symbolic event. According to reports on the voting process, 18 Knesset members from the Arab parties supported the move, while the Haredi factions sided with Benjamin Netanyahu. The result transfers control of the legislature's agenda to the Change Bloc, even before the government has been formed, and proves that it is possible to form a cross-bloc parliamentary majority.

But here a fundamental distinction is required. A majority to elect a Knesset Speaker is not the same as a majority capable of swearing in a government, passing a budget, and ensuring stability throughout a term. The vote for Kahane demonstrated tactical coordination ability, but has not yet proven governance ability. Bridging this gap is the main challenge now facing Gadi Eisenkot.

Two parallel runways to expand maneuvering space

In parallel with the parliamentary process, two political channels of strategic significance are developing beneath the surface. Avigdor Lieberman may re-establish cooperation with the Haredi parties, while Yoav Segalovich may serve as a bridge between Mansour Abbas and Ra'am and the forming government. These are not necessarily paths that will lead to the same coalition, but their very existence expands the possibilities of the Change Bloc and reduces its dependence on a single political partner.

In the Lieberman era – the ultra-OrthodoxThe infrastructure for dialogue already exists. The draft draft that Lieberman presented in 2018 and which previously received agreement in principle from Haredi elements is returning to the political discourse. According to various publications, contacts are taking place between his entourage and senior figures in the Haredi sector. Although the fundamental dispute over the issue of equality of burden remains, the political question is whether a practical arrangement can be formulated that will allow cooperation without either side being perceived as having given up on its core principles.

Ziir Saglowicz – RAAM, the logic is completely different. The common denominator is not compromise on issues of religion and state, but the promotion of practical civil policy. Seglowicz brings with him experience in leading the inter-systemic government struggle against crime in Arab society, and Abbas based his political path on translating parliamentary power into achievements on the ground.

Politics of risk management

Here the tactical importance of the two channels becomes clear: Lieberman does not have to bring the Haredim into the coalition for the mere dialogue with them to change the balance of power, and Segalovich does not have to ensure that Ra'am joins the government in order to create an option for parliamentary support. The multitude of alternatives weakens the blackmailing power of the potential partners, but does not relieve the government component of the need to decide between them.

At this point in time, all players have something to lose:

  • Lieberman May pay a public price for being flexible towards the ultra-Orthodox.
  • The Haredi parties They risk breaking away from Netanyahu without ensuring their full demands are met.
  • Abbas May lose legitimacy if it provides support without clear civic return.
  • Naftali Bennett resigns as head of the Change Bloc They will be required to explain to their voters the gap between election promises and the coalition's constraints.

However, even the refusal to compromise has a heavy price tag. Continuing the stalemate could lead to another round of elections, deepening the instability of the government, and paralyzing decision-making on critical issues. Compromise, in this context, is not an ideological whim but a rational calculation of risk management.

Eisenkot's test: From tactical majority to a functioning government

Gadi Eisenkot's challenge will be to cast these conflicting interests into a governing framework with a clear direction. The shared desire to replace Netanyahu is an effective political glue for achieving a majority in the Knesset, but it is no substitute for an agreed-upon government program. The core issues, the conscription law, internal security, the judicial system, the state budget, and relations between the government and Arab society, will require clear decisions, not just a rejection of the disputes.

Political experience teaches that complex coalitions are not measured solely by the number of seats they hold, but by the quality of the institutional mechanisms that enable them to manage crises without falling apart. The 66 fingers raised in favor of Matan Kahane proved that it is possible to form a majority for change; now Eisenkot will have to prove that this majority can be translated into governing capacity. The true test of the next government will not be the size of the concessions each partner agrees to make on the way to it, but the public value that will actually be created from it.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the newsroom: At watsap • By email

Dr. Aqab Zidan
Dr. Aqab Zidan
Public policy and local government researcher. His doctoral dissertation, academic articles, and published columns deal with structural reforms in local and central government, democracy, privatization, the Arab minority in Israel, and good governance. A major in the reserves, he is active in the Home Front Command and the Recruitment Bureau in Haifa. He worked at the Ministry of Finance in the Customs and VAT Department for about a decade. He has been the director of the Human Capital Management Department in the Dalit El Carmel Local Council for five years.

Articles related to this topic

תגובה 1

  1. A significant portion of the column feels like wishful thinking rather than an opinion column, but that is of course the prerogative of the writer of the article in the only democratic country in the region.
    The majority of the Israeli public does not seem to view the Joint and Ram parties as morally legitimate, and therefore it must be assumed that the votes in which they participate (and influence the outcome) are not morally legitimate.
    Therefore, we should hope for repeat elections in the near future ((if there is no unity government or a left-wing government with Haredim))
    Assuming that the audience of those parties will continue the trend of radicalization and voting for those parties that support Palestine, hopefully the general public will show vigilance this time and instead of voting for many parties with many agendas, will act like the aforementioned public and will also target the right-wing parties that will hopefully be able to achieve a majority and return the Land of Israel and the Jewish state to sanity before it deteriorates like the countries of Europe or, no less, to a Jewish state that your brothers, God forbid, control.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Cafe-Tzur in Acre • A period when the north of the country competed bravely against the center

A young, sturdy redhead who spoke fluent Arabic managed to establish contact with Arab farmers in Lebanon during the austerity period. On his back he carried tons of sacks of onions that he had bought...

A 77-year-old hiker was rescued from the Ma'apilim Stream in the Carmel Nature Reserve after falling and rolling in the area.

(Hai Pa) – Volunteers from the Israel Police's "Galil-Carmel" rescue unit recently completed a complex rescue of a 77-year-old hiker, a resident of Migdal HaEmek, who was injured...

Two pedestrians were hit by a vehicle on Almog Street in Haifa

(Hai Pa) – Two women in their 60s were hit by a vehicle while walking on Almog Street in Haifa. Magen David Adom teams were called to the scene, provided initial medical treatment...

On Life From the Heart • A Home Afternoon

She is a friend of 45 years, she announces that she will come to the house for lunch. Meeting with her is like a therapy session for me / for her I brought my mental flexibility, I changed my work schedule,...

Flower of the week • Shooting star

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column, we will always present one of the Carmel flowers, at the same time as it appears in the field, and you will be invited to visit it in one of the places where...