Explosive sounds will be heard from Raphael's David Institute due to a planned and controlled experiment

Raphael was delivered to the mouth - News Corporation: Today (Tuesday, 10/13/26)...

Dania residents demand safety: Fight over crosswalks renews after girl's accident

(Live here) – The struggle of the residents of the Danya neighborhood in Haifa...

Serious car accident on Tovim Street in Haifa – four injured

(Live here) – A serious car accident occurred on Tovim Street...

Marshes in Israel: About the dangers that almost no one knows about

Marshes are something we are used to associating with the Amazon, the Gulf...

Under the Radar: Mysterious Beetle Mortality at Tel Shikmona

Every time I go out into the field, my eyes are fixed on the ground, as if...

"The Twin Palaces" – Luxury of the Past on the Way to Talpiot Market 

On Yechiel Street, which climbs from the lower city towards the market complex...

Flower of the Week • Canadian summer

The Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons of the year. In this column we will represent...

No one is in the news.

Uri Sharon from Haifa visits the streets, sees the people,...

The year 1922 – Many historical events have disappeared, forgotten, but not this one

Our tireless friend Mickey Gottschalk revealed the incident that occurred...

Cantons within a State: The Collapse of Governance in the Negev and the Mixed Cities | Opinion Column

In the events of May 2021 during Operation "Guardian of Walls," for example, violent clashes, arson, and damage to property occurred. Governance collapsed, and the Negev and the cities involved were not in our hands.

The State of Israel of recent years has been losing its sovereign continuity, and increasingly resembles a perforated and bleeding Swiss cheese. 11 mixed cities of Jews and Arabs (Ramla, Lod, Acre, Haifa, and more) and the wider Negev have long been out of full control of the authorities, and these holes in the heart of the national home are growing, to the point of a tangible, daily, and immediate danger to the national security of us all.

As sovereignty and governance recede, a dangerous vacuum is created. In the Negev and the cities involved, unbridled violence, organized nationalist crime, and protection money collection run rampant, reminiscent of Wild West arenas where the laws of the land are merely recommendations. The direct and grim result is that Israel is de facto becoming a decentralized “state of cantons,” isolated enclaves where the deterrent power of the Israel Police and law enforcement agencies is almost nonexistent, as we have already painfully learned in the severe violent incidents of recent years.

Alongside the loss of land and police control, the wide-ranging demographic danger between the sea and the Jordan is also becoming more acute. Approximately 6 million Arab residents live in the territories of Judea, Samaria and Gaza, and over 2 million Arab citizens live within the Green Line. This is a human mass that includes approximately 8 million Arabs and 8 million Jews in the area between the Jordan and the sea, a figure that presents an unprecedented and disturbing demographic imbalance with the Jewish population.

The deadly combination of a tense demographic balance, a complete loss of control over the Negev lands, and the weakening of the social fabric in the mixed cities is no longer a local nuisance that can be contained. It is a strategic threat of the first order. Without root causes, iron-clad enforcement, and the restoration of governance at all costs, the holes in Israel's map will continue to grow, until the entire national structure collapses.

Did the article interest you?

Contact the newsroom: At watsap • By email

Dr. Jacob Rob
Dr. Jacob Rob
He holds a postdoctoral degree in national security, and is a researcher and writer in the fields of national security, law, international economics, and psychology. His writings are published in a variety of websites and journals, and have been read in 74 countries. He is a member of the Writers' Association, and combines academic research with clear writing for a broad audience.

Articles related to this topic

תגובה 1

  1. Correct and accurate article.
    Here we are talking about 11 mixed cities. We need to pay attention to other cities throughout the Land of Israel where Arab immigration is beginning, which may lead to Jews leaving first the building, then the neighborhood, then the city, which may slowly turn from Jewish to mixed. We need to pay attention, for example, to Haifa, which was a mixed city, but still had segregated neighborhoods, and the situation is slowly deteriorating (not necessarily always security-related, but demographic/national) and the neighborhoods have become and are becoming mixed. Arabs are buying and renting apartments in them, and this is legal from their perspective, but it is unfair.
    In practice today, mainly ultra-Orthodox cities and settlements manage to maintain a Jewish character, while secular cities, if you can call them that, are depraved and their character is not protected.
    The leaders of the country must make fateful decisions, and if not for a two-state solution for two peoples, then at least for the declaration of Jewish cities where Arabs will not be able to live, and on the other hand, Arab cities where Jews will not be able to live (which in practice happens a lot there), and there will be 11 mixed cities, as listed here, open to residence for the entire population when a choice is given, and in them too Jewish/Arab/mixed neighborhoods will be declared.
    And every person and family will choose where to build their home and buy/rent an apartment without fear that their city/neighborhood will eventually change its appearance.
    The state also needs to build a large, developed Arab city for hundreds of thousands of Arabs with high-rise construction so that they can purchase quality apartments and also provide them with housing solutions, good schools for their children, and employment solutions without the need to go to Jewish cities.
    This is challenging and requires budgets, but otherwise, in my opinion, without constitutional intervention, the next generation will most likely find itself living in a binational state in even larger parts, and the cantons here that have been described negatively will also shrink further.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Rambam Honors Evening: Honors and Medical Innovation Awards – Watch

(Hai Pa) - The annual appreciation evening of the Rambam Medical Center was held in Haifa on October 15, 2026, with the participation of medical professionals and public figures. After a meeting and a light meal...

A two-year-old toddler choked on a grape in a garden in Usafiya – her life was saved thanks to the MDA team.

(Hai Pa) – Last night (Thursday), at 20:48 PM, a two-year-old toddler choked on a grape during an event at an event park in Usafiya. An MDA team that arrived at the scene provided her with treatment...

Serious car accident on Tovim Street in Haifa – four injured

(Hai Fa) – A serious car accident occurred on Tovim Street in Haifa, near the Electric Company, involving two vehicles. Four people were injured in the accident, including a woman...

Dozens protested in front of the refineries in Haifa demanding the plant be closed – watch

(Live here) – Several dozen people demonstrated this evening, October 15, 2026, in front of the entrance gate to the refineries in Haifa, in protest of a significant leak of materials...

A new logistical connection between India, Israel and the West • Haifa Port as a key point in the new international economic corridor

At the Mare Med conference held in Tel Aviv, Captain Sumit Chauhan, President of the Port of Haifa, presented the economic and logistical potential of the IMEC corridor - the India-Middle East-Europe corridor...