From Dudu Topaz's cheesy speech, through Yair Garbuz's talisman-kissing to the latest statements by Yinon Magal and Galia Albin — the names change, the camps change, but the test remains the same: Are we able to disagree with each other without belittling each other?
There are moments when it seems like Israeli society is making progress, and then an election comes along and sets us back decades. Instead of talking about security, the cost of living, education, and the future of our children, we are once again arguing about origin, accent, tradition, and most of all, one outrageous question: Who here deserves to be considered intelligent, and who needs to prove that they are capable of thinking for themselves?
The sectarian demon never went away. It simply learned to change form. Sometimes it disguises itself as humor, sometimes as political criticism, and sometimes it goes on air in a television studio, wrapped in self-confidence and the feeling that anything is permitted in the name of political struggle.
The storm surrounding Yinon Magal's remarks illustrates how low public discourse can go. On the "Patriots" program, Magal called Gadi Eisenkot a "monkey," and in his remarks he also referred to the claim that elitist Ashkenazi elements are behind him and manipulating him. In light of the storm his remarks caused, Magal tried to explain his remarks, noting that he used the word "monkey" as a term from the world of crime to mean a person, i.e., an "ape" manipulated by others, and not with the intention of referring to Eisenkot's appearance.
Magal's words also reached my immediate circle and I received calls from friends who urged me to respond, respond.
He hurt us even though we are Likud members, he hurt all the Eastern communities, they explained.
I wondered how to address the issue, how to respond. Then on second thought I said, there's no point in responding directly to these slanderous words. I have no intention of getting angry and stooping to low places, that's not my style either. Eastern Jews have long since stopped having to prove anything to anyone. But you can't ignore the problematic nature of the language chosen. When a derogatory image is incorporated into a political discussion, in which a person's origin is also emphasized, a justified question arises about the message that was received by the public. It is permissible to criticize Eisenkot, it is permissible to challenge his judgment, his positions, and his suitability for leadership, but why do you have to humiliate a person in order to criticize him? Since when did the insulting nickname become a substitute for a substantive argument?
From the other side came the statement of businesswoman Galia Albin, who referred to Netanyahu voters, known as "Bibists," in an interview on Avi Shoshan's podcast. Albin linked support for Netanyahu to the voters' Mizrahi origin, and raised the question of whether there is a connection between the hand that inserts a ballot and the brain. She even spoke about women in Sderot and Dimona who support Netanyahu, even though, according to her, they experienced vulnerability following the events of October 7. In this case too, one can understand her political frustration. One can ask why citizens continue to support a leader who, in the critic's opinion, has failed. It is possible and necessary to conduct a pointed discussion about responsibility, discretion, and decisions at the ballot box. But as soon as criticism of a political choice becomes a question of the thinking ability of an entire public and when this is linked to its origin, it ceases to be substantive criticism and becomes arrogance.
I'll tell you a little secret: not all Netanyahu voters are from the Mizrahi community, and not all Mizrahi community voters vote for Netanyahu. It may sound surprising, but among Likud voters there are also Ashkenazim, highly educated people, businessmen, and citizens from all walks of life, who vote out of a very clear ideological and ethical worldview, in the spirit of the founding father, Jabotinsky, and not just out of loyalty to a leader, no matter how great he may be.
They don't have to agree with Albin, with any commentator, or with the writer of this article, to be considered thinking people. A citizen doesn't have to vote like me for me to recognize their intelligence. Each camp has quotes, videos, and an archive of embarrassing statements by its opponents. But if every time the opposing side crosses the line we exclaim, and when it comes from our camp, we rush to provide it with explanations, we haven't fought racism. We've just recruited it to the service of our camp.
Some people look down on right-wing voters because they are convinced that they are captives of propaganda. Some people look down on left-wing voters because they see them as a disconnected elite. Some people flaunt a candidate's Eastern identity to present him as authentic, and some people emphasize his origin to claim that he is manipulated by others. In all cases, the person disappears behind the label, they call it identity politics.
The public doesn't need leaders who will defend its honor only when the insult comes from the opposing camp. It also needs leaders and opinion leaders who are able to raise a flag and say to their friends within the camp: Hey, this is where you crossed the line.
A healthy democracy needs harsh criticism, debate, and tough questions. But it also needs a red line: origin, skin color, accent, or religious tradition are not a measure of a person's worth. The Mizrahi public does not need patrons to explain to them how to vote, nor politicians who remember their identity only when it serves them. They are entitled to respect, equality, and substantive criticism, just like any other public.
The same rule applies to everyone. A person should not be protected from all criticism just because they were hurt, but neither should the harm they suffered be turned into a joke or a tool for garnering votes. In the run-up to the elections, every candidate, commentator and public figure should ask themselves a simple question: Do the things I say help the public understand reality, or only deepen the insult and hatred? The State of Israel cannot afford to continue arguing at the ballot box and at the same time label other citizens as less intelligent, less worthy or less Israeli.
It's time to remove the sectarian demon from the campaign, not to silence the past, but to stop enslaving the future to it.
From Dudu Topaz's tsachchachim speech, through Yair Garbuz's mascot-kissing to the latest statements by Yinon Magal and Galia Albin, the names change, the camps change, but the test remains the same: Are we able to disagree with each other without denigrating each other? Are we able to disagree with each other without descending into personal/sectarian lines? For now, the answer seems to be no.
The writer is the spokesperson for the Federation of Moroccan Jewry.


This was already before Rabin's assassination, barbaric incitement with voices of hatred and insults.
Now it's Yinon Magal and the poor bully of the Minister of Pitah
The ethnic demon has not died out, but it cannot be compared to the days of the founding of the state. It turns out that more than 3 generations are needed to eradicate it. I still remember the days when Yiddish was the entrance ticket, the high schools were purely Ashkenazi, not to mention the institutions of higher education, when parents boycotted their children who married Mizrahi and adopted their grandchildren. My mother was the queen of demons. She threw Moroccan suitors out of the house and did not accept Mizrahi friends, to put it mildly. I fought with her a lot about it. My father was also not righteous on the subject, but he did not reach her ankles. Her contempt and disdain were atrocious. Later she calmed down…. As mentioned, it takes more than 3 generations to bury the ethnic demon.
There is no sectarian demon. The concept of 'monkey' is a well-known and recognized concept in the criminal world. Even when he said this, he explained that it was actually a Mizrahi-Mohammedan or a monkey who puts Ashkenazim on the left in order to try to bring votes from the right-wing bloc.
For those who know!
Trying to justify Yinon Magal, the trash channel's rag?