(Live here is the news corporation of Haifa and the surrounding area) City Council member Kirill Kratnik is demanding that the municipality conduct a physical and documented inspection of all public shelters and parking lots approved to serve as emergency shelters, present certificates of correction of past deficiencies, and train the teams responsible for opening and operating them. Among his demands: publishing an initial status report within 48 hours and making the information available to the public in Hebrew, Arabic, and Russian.
In light of public concerns about a security escalation, Haifa City Council member Kirill Kartnik is demanding that the Haifa Municipality urgently conduct a comprehensive inspection of all public shelters and parking lots that have been approved to serve as shelter for residents in times of emergency.

In his appeal to the municipality, Kartnik emphasizes that Haifa residents cannot discover, precisely during an alarm, that a shelter is not operational, that the entrance gate to the parking lot is locked, or that the team responsible for opening it has not yet arrived. According to him, the readiness of the municipal defense system must be checked in advance and be backed up by documentation and permits.
He bases his demand, among other things, on the Haifa Municipality's announcement of 12/4/26, which stated that many public shelters were damaged by acts of vandalism and that the municipality is working to repair the damage and restore them to full functionality. In the same announcement, the municipality noted that the activity of the municipal teams in the underground parking lots has ended, their use for extended stays has been discontinued, and entry to them in the event of an alarm will only be permitted during operating hours.
In addition, Kartnik refers to the municipality's auditor's report for 2023, which dealt with the use of private shelters. The report, on page 23, documented gaps related to the lack of execution permits and delivery protocols, as well as discrepancies between the work orders and the work actually performed in the shelters for which bills were paid. The auditor recommended conducting inspection tours of all the shelters used as part of the project and comparing the work ordered with the execution on the ground.
The State Comptroller's report from January 2026, which dealt with protection and reception in local authorities, also pointed to gaps in capacity in public shelters at the national level and the need to strengthen supervision and control.
Kartnik emphasizes that the audit findings do not necessarily indicate the current state of the shelters in Haifa, but require the municipality to present an up-to-date, detailed, and documented picture of the situation: what has been repaired, what has been inspected, and who confirmed that each facility is indeed fit for use.

The demands presented by the council member to the municipality:
- Physical inspection of all public shelters: Inspection of access routes, emergency exits, doors, windows, electrical systems, emergency lighting, ventilation, cleanliness and absence of hazards, moisture and flooding. Each inspection will be documented, indicating the date of the inspection and the identity of the inspector.
- Checking the parking lots approved as shelters: Examining permits for use of parking lots, permitted areas for parking, opening of gates, access routes, signage, accessibility, and parking conditions. In addition, each parking lot must be assigned a responsible and alternate parking lot, staffing team, and emergency opening times, including at night and on weekends.
- Presenting references to correct past deficiencies: Receive a list of the public shelters that were damaged, details of the work that was done, and certificates indicating their proper functioning after the repairs. Also, please know whether a comprehensive inspection was carried out in accordance with the recommendations of the municipal auditor regarding the private shelters' renovation project, and what emerged from it.
- Municipal team practice: Checking the availability of drives and replacements, communication means and equipment, and practicing opening shelters and parking lots in scenarios of power outages or loss of communications. The exercise will include the 106 hotline, the security department, and field teams, while measuring response times.
- Submitting a status report within 48 hours: Kartnik demands an initial report detailing how many facilities were tested, how many were found to be qualified, what deficiencies were discovered, and what has not yet been corrected. A responsible party and a schedule for correction will be defined for each deficiency. In places that are not available for protection, an alternative solution must be arranged and published in coordination with the authorized parties.

In addition, Kartnik demands that the municipality publish up-to-date and clear information to the public in Hebrew, Arabic, and Russian, which will include the location of the approved spaces, their accessibility, and the conditions for their opening. He says that it is necessary to ensure that the public knows in advance where to go in the event of an alarm, in accordance with the instructions of the authorized authorities.
At the end of his appeal, he makes it clear that he will not be satisfied with general statements that the municipality is prepared for an emergency, and that data, test results, repair dates, and a clear division of responsibility are required. He also demands immediate approval for the start of the tests, the name of the municipal entity that will coordinate their execution, and the timetable for their completion.
The Haifa Municipality gave a response:
"The Haifa Municipality is operating in full routine, in accordance with the Home Front Command's policies and guidelines, which have not changed. The municipality maintains ongoing contact with the Home Front Command, is prepared for any scenario, and will act in accordance with its guidelines as necessary."
"All public shelters in the city, as well as the Carmelit stations (except Paris Square, which is not approved for use as a shelter) that serve as protected spaces, are fully operational and prepared to open automatically upon sounding an alarm. We emphasize that currently there is no change in the defense situation, and routine in the city continues as usual."


100 people in Haifa without access to public shelter near their homes
Haifa Municipality Hate Crime Against Its Residents Did Not Build Shelters Even 20 Years After the Second Lebanon War
Deals with illusory solutions of private parking lots that will be forced to become shelters
You don't check the condition of the few shelters in the neighborhoods.
There are not enough shelters in schools for all students – a well-known blunder by the Ministry of Education that does nothing about the issue
😍Just Care Tonic!
I have long wondered about the "gap" between the "news" about the possibility of renewing the WAR and the "readiness"
For protection/defense in WHERE so as not to experience WIRE anymore and to cover yourself only with WORDS, which does not provide "shelter" nor "cover"!!!@😭
Come on, the "hour of labor" has arrived again as the "hour of testing": As a song or as a poem, it is the same "poetry" of all the "shelters" without distinction. "That which distinguishes between the sacred and the profane" = "Shelter - rejects Shabbat," said the "Baba Metzia" already for a long time...!!!😭