Thanks to him, thanks to them • Independence Day 2025

The Sachna – Secrets of the Blue Spring: When ornamental fish, stalactite caves and wild nature meet at the foot of Mount Gilboa

In the heart of the Valley of Springs, at the foot of the Gilboa, lies one of his most...

Haifa – A Taste of the Past • Customs and Events from the Past

The mother-in-law worried about the disappearance of her son-in-law, a problem from the month of Cheshon, 1923:...

Heavy fever • Song

Forecasters warn that the sun is waking up from its summer sleep. These will be the days of air conditioning and fans. We must drink a lot of this...

Passport to Freedom • Song

The Age of Alexander returned to the sparrow. The Age of Alexander left behind the fire of the dragon. What "kept...

The Sachna – Secrets of the Blue Spring: When ornamental fish, stalactite caves and wild nature meet at the foot of Mount Gilboa

In the heart of the Valley of Springs, at the foot of the Gilboa, lies one of his most...

Suspected murder in Kiryat Yam

(Live) - A man was murdered and another man was injured in a...

Yedidiya-Aria Gottlieb was born on Tammuz 1.8.29, XNUMX (XNUMX) in the town of Tszybinia in western Poland, where Israel Avi's family also lived. Yedidiya-Aria immigrated to Israel with his family when he was six years old and at nineteen he joined the defense of Haifa as a machine gunner.

On the 22.4.48th of Nisan XNUMX (XNUMX), during the Battle of Haifa in the War of Independence, the battle known as "The Clearing of the Bitterness", Yedidia-Aria was hit by an Arab sniper's bullet and killed. Yedidia-Aria is buried in the military cemetery in Haifa.
Yedidia-Aria's parents were older than my parents and were a kind of substitute for the parents they didn't have, and with them we could talk at length about the town, its people, and the Jewish destiny.

As a child, I would accompany my parents on Shabbat when they went to visit the Gottlieb family in their small, modest apartment on Pevzner Street in Haifa. I had not yet been told about my son's fall, but even as a five-year-old girl, I felt the silent, uncompromising presence of the heavy, constricted sadness that pervaded the house, which was always a little dark.

Only in my adulthood did I come to understand the sense of loss that never ends and the pain of parents that never passes but only changes. When I first visited the military cemetery in Haifa with my parents and saw the white, uniform tombstones, arranged in exemplary order, it seemed to me that an attempt was being made to organize the sadness and pain. There was an endless love of families, endless love and pain.

Later, my father Israel told me that the fall of nineteen-year-old Yedidia-Aria in battle broke his parents. They broke not with a loud voice, not with a noise, but with a thin, silent voice, with a thin, penetrating break that came from the heart. They were quiet people.

Every Passover Eve in our house, since the day of the fall of Yedidia-Aria, my father, before the beginning of the Seder, would ask everyone present to stand up and say: Our lives here are possible only because of the life that our Yedidia-Aria gave us on Passover Eve 5758. We must remember him and his friends because today we celebrate the holiday of Passover, the holiday of freedom, only because of them.

Dad is gone and all that remains are the public ceremonies on Memorial Day. Every now and then the question arises as to how much the bereaved families need Memorial Day, since for them every day is Memorial Day.

From conversations with bereaved families, I learned that for them the ceremonies are of great importance and are meaningful, because they strengthen the sense of partnership, recognition, understanding and social embrace. "The government will not send to our cemetery a minister who did not serve in the IDF," said a bereaved mother on the radio.

The sharp edges of pain can never be blurred. Memory is alive and well, both personal memory and public memory.

contact: At watsapBy email

Aliza Shanar
Aliza Shanar
Chairwoman of the Haifa History Association, former rector of the University of Haifa, researcher of Jewish and Israeli culture, gender and multiculturalism.

More articles from the same reporter

2 תגובות

  1. Dear Aliza. A meaningful story. Every family should adopt a bereaved family, give them a sense of empathy and love and be grateful for our very existence. Don't leave any family alone during the holidays.

  2. Dear Aliza, your story is very moving. Indeed, the bereaved families live with grief every day and time does not heal but rather increases the longing.

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Summer camps 2025 in Haifa and the surrounding area

Youth who love science and technology • Summer workshops 2025 at the Technion Summer camps and summer camps operators in Haifa and the surrounding area: You are invited to contact us for advertising purposes. Noga Carmi • 052-2410689...

A missile from Yemen was launched overnight towards the Dan Bloc – 18/5/25 02:02 (immediately after the Eurovision Song Contest)

(Hai Fa) - The Houthis continue to fire ballistic missiles at Israel in an attempt to cripple Ben Gurion Airport. Millions rushed to shelters late at night (18/5/25 02:02, after the broadcast...

Maccabi Haifa's youth team won the championship 

In a good and successful time and after leading the Youth Super League table since the eighth round and for 23 games, the youth team of the Maccabi Haifa Football Club "Maccabi...

Kitesurfing: A record day at the fortress beach in Atlit 16/5/25 • Watch the broadcast from the water, including a surprise in the middle of the sea – at the end of the article

(Live here by the sea) - During the spring, northerly winds blow from noon until evening. This is the period when kitesurfers from all over the country gather at the fortress beach in Atlit...

Viper snake caught in French Carmel – 16/5/25

(Live here) - The vipers are at their peak activity now - they are hungry after their winter hibernation and they are thirsty for water. Caution is required when you walk...