(live here in education) - The tribunal of the teachers' organization determined in a reasoned verdict, that the principal of Harieli's Beit Biram high school, Mandy Rabinovitch, will be removed from the teachers' organization for 8 years, of which 5 will actually be. According to Bin Hadin, Rabinovitch violated the organization's instructions when he issued trips contrary to the sanctions announced by the organization. Rabinovitch, for his part, stands behind his choice, claiming that in such a complex year, students should not be prevented from going on trips, adding that he is not bothered by the exclusion.
The chairman of the teachers' organization, Ran Erez, explains in the letter dealing with the handover of shield marks (dated 11/07/24) the need for sanctions by the teachers' organization:
"For two years we have been working without a collective agreement to improve our wages and working conditions. The Ministry of Finance is presenting a signing of a collective agreement by agreeing to personal contracts for teachers and administrators, while harming the rights of teachers and administrators and organized work, as well as harming social solidarity and the economic and occupational security of all of us...
It is very serious that a public of administrators and teachers are trying to please their employers and cooperate with them while seriously harming the solidarity and rights of teachers and administrators by way of a deliberate violation of the organization's instructions when it comes to carrying out the sanctions...
The struggle we are now waging is done in order to prevent salary deductions from you and to reduce as much as possible the harm to the students. A strike is easier to manage, but it hurts both teachers and students, and so far we have been careful not to do so, especially given the cliff of times.
The violation of the sanctions by administrators and teachers has the effect of strengthening the employers and the ministries of finance and education when the only pressure left on them is greatly weakened. This directly harms the interest of the teachers and administrators and weakens the organizational power that is meant to protect everyone."
Requirement to sign an employment agreement with the Treasury
The teachers' sanctions include school activities until 15:30 p.m. only and in addition grades are not published. The intention behind the sanctions is to get the Ministry of Finance to sign an employment agreement with the teachers of the teachers' organization, when the teachers are currently working without an agreement.
Contrary to Erez's claim that the purpose of the sanctions is to protect the teachers, and this while trying to reduce the harm to the students (for this reason it was also decided not to hold a full strike), Rabinovitch claims that the sanctions are disproportionate and only the students suffer from it.
"Fear of foreign considerations"
"The teachers' organization is led by a figure who does not serve it and harms the teachers," he claims Mandy Rabinovitch. "Teachers in the State of Israel deserve a different character, who will bring achievements. I'm not saying that the struggle is not important, that's another discussion. My argument is that there should be proportionality. It's not possible that only the students are the ones who suffer. In such a difficult year, it doesn't make sense to cancel an annual trip, certainly not It is possible that some schools received the approval for the trip and some did not, and this when there is no transparency in the matter. The schools that received a negative answer from the exception committee and could not go on an annual trip, did not receive any explanation for the decision, so there is a concern that foreign considerations are involved."
"Erez refused to withdraw"
"After the trip was already postponed from November and the trip to Poland was canceled as well, the demand of the 12th grade students and parents was to go on the trip," says Rabinovitch. "I asked Maren Erez to make an exception, personally. These are children who have gone through corona and war, so it is clear to any reasonable person that they must go on a journey, but Erez decided not to go back on his decision.
The parents, along with the teachers, the GNA instructors, and the members of the teachers' union, demanded that the trip be canceled, and so we did. On the last day of the trip, Erez sent me the lawsuit. In the court, I said that I did not violate the terms of the sanctions. If the teachers who went out are teachers of the Histadrut, we also took out the 10th grade campaign, it also went out only with the Histadrut employees."
"The teachers' organization sabotages education"
"It was decided to remove me from the teachers' organization, but I already said there that I am not interested in being part of a teachers' organization that makes wrong and unethical decisions. The instruction not to take the trips is an illegal educational instruction, which a black flag wavers over, therefore it should not be carried out. I was also not willing to hold the graduation parties.
The teachers' organization today sabotages education and does not help its teachers. We tried to convince Ran Erez to approve giving grades in math and English and not to "burn" the students' freedom, so that they would have to study for the high school diploma while they might have gotten a good grade. We received a snarky and sarcastic reply letter, which treated the children's time as if it didn't count and nothing would happen if children studied for matriculation even though they had already received a good grade.
Erez said that he is allowing the scores to be released because I want to put pressure on the Ministry of Defense, because a situation will arise where 12th grade students will not be able to enlist because they will be busy improving matriculation, and thus the Ministry of Defense will put pressure on the Ministry of Finance. Everyone is harmed and all means are kosher.
Rabinovitch adds: "Ran Erez should vacate his place after 27 years as chairman of the teachers' organization. We tried to convince those who could, that the grades must be released to the students, and we failed. We have no one to talk to.
All the managers talk to him, and he doesn't listen to anyone. Tens of thousands of teachers eventually decided to transfer the grades to the students, and voted a vote of no confidence in Baran Erez.
Because of the intimidation of the teachers' organization, there are teachers who did not pass the grades and their students do not know what the shield and matriculation grades are. Some of the students will not pass the matriculation exam in the second year, because they do not have the strength to pass after this year and when they find out that they received bad grades, they will no longer have a way to correct them."
"Harming the students is immoral, especially in a year like this. They also hurt the teachers and the status of the teacher. The bullies create a conflict between teachers, parents and students. We, the administrators, absorb the fire from everyone. We tried to convince Erez to go back on the decision not to release the grades. The 2nd year deadline in Aglit is already lost , there is only a sophomore year left in math. This person is busy chasing a school principal to make a move on me and the reali and prove that he is strong, when it falls apart in his hands he needs to do two things today: release the grades and let someone else fill the position and get an agreement "
"Erez came uninvited to our teachers' room. They told him, how do you do it in a year like this, and he said in our teachers' room, that the war ended a long time ago. History will not forget the one who only tried to promote his sector and in the end only hurt him. 27 years is more every".
Today on B network Ran Erez bitter that teachers should not be under pressure because they are also mothers and wives. "The statement that Ran Erez said online today proves more than anything who we are dealing with, not only a man who is heartless towards the students but also misogynistic and hurts his teachers without even blinking an eye."
The tribunal of the teachers' organization: "It is impossible for Rabinowitz to violate the sanctions, when the teachers' organization acted in his favor two years ago"
The tribunal of the teachers' organization discussed the petition against Rabinovitch, when in the hearing Erez explained that the petition was filed after Rabinovitch took the 11th and 12th grades out for annual trips. Rabinovitch asked to postpone the hearing on the petition, and during the postponement he took out another layer for the trip - the 10th layer.
In the discussion, Erez pointed out that in recent years the teachers' organization helped the Reali school when it was in financial distress, and with the help of the organization, the school signed a new collective agreement. In addition, Erez claimed that the organization also helped Rabinovich personally, when two years ago he was on the verge of being fired and with the help of the organization this was avoided.
Erez claimed, and the court agreed with the claim, that it is unthinkable that the teachers' organization would help the members of the organization when they need help, but when the teachers' organization announces sanctions to protect the working conditions of the teachers, the members of the organization will refuse to cooperate with it.
The court ruled that Rabinovitch violated the instructions of the teachers' organization:
According to the sanctions, the organization's teachers' school day will end at 15:30 p.m., so that trips of more than one day will take place after receiving approval from the organization's Exceptions Committee. Rabinovitch authorized the study levels at the school to go on a trip one after the other. Regarding the 3th layer, Rabinovitch claimed in the court that it was an educator who took his class on a 15-day trip, meaning that it was the educator's decision. The court rejected the claim. Regarding the 30th layer, the court stated that no explanation was given regarding the decision to take her on a trip Regarding the twelfth grade, Rabinovich claimed that he instructed the teachers to sit in the hotel rooms from XNUMX:XNUMX p.m., or to return to their homes and arrive again the next day, and in any case, he claimed, they were not members of the organization.
The court rejected the claim stating that the school principals are supposed to help the organization with the sanctions and not sabotage them by using teachers who are members of the Histadrut. The court also firmly rejected Rabinovitch's claim that it was an illegal instruction.
According to the court, it is not possible for a manager or teacher to decide on his own which instruction to accept and which not to accept. In addition, it is claimed that Rabinovitch did not contact the teachers' organization in writing before leaving for the trip with the claim that in his opinion it was illegal teaching. At the same time, the court noted that the pressures placed on a school principal regarding the 12th grade trip are understandable, and this is exactly why the Exceptions Committee exists.
The ruling also stated that a member of an organization has a duty to obey the organization's instructions in any case, and especially in cases of sanctions, and that the strength of the teachers' organization stems from the fact that behind it are members who stand with it in every struggle it leads, and there cannot be a situation where the organization is trying to act on behalf of the teachers and they do not share with it action.
The verdict will hang in the teachers' room
In the verdict, it was determined, as mentioned, that Rabinowitz leaves and is removed from his membership in the organization for a period of 8 years, 5 years of actual removal and 3 years of probation.
The meaning of the conditional suspension for 3 years is that if Rabinovitch violates the instructions of the teachers' organization during the next two years, he will be suspended for another 3 years beyond the stipulated 5. In addition, the anonymous verdict will be published on the organization's website and in Bitown, and will also be posted on the bulletin board in the teachers' room at Beit Biram.
What do you think teachers and administrators will not like in the eyes of the malicious government, which is built on the words of both men and women.
What a king the man is, it's a shame there aren't others who have done something like him.
It is not clear why students are prevented from traveling during such a difficult time. It's hard for them too. Instead of putting this manager as a stain on the head, they keep him away. A disgrace to the state and to the teacher's organization. Damn you Ran Erez, you destroyed our child's happiness and well-being.
How long will this cedar remain the chairman? He has been there for years and there are no democratic elections in this organization?
An exemplary educator
All the best to him
who sees the welfare of the students before his eyes
And not a little politics
What exactly is the benefit of the students, I didn't understand as soon as politics enters education, it is urgent to boycott a school bully, it never happened in my life, and yes, it calls for a boycott.
Anyone who thinks about long-term education should think about what kind of teachers will teach the students if the conditions and teachers' pay do not attract people to teaching.
The current government does not think about the future of the students and the future of the teachers.
Those who think only of the short term are harming the future of the country.
All the best to Mandy Rabinovitch. A man of values, the best interests of the students are in front of his eyes. It's time for Ran Erez to go home.
What a man this manager is
A real cannon
Well done
Another victim of all the institutional poisoning is forbidden, to be authentic for them, the prison should be run through strict rules and if there is a teacher, an enterprising guide removed from the corporation...a teacher influences eternity strengthens you, you have not lost light, you cannot run from darkness successfully
The manager Sahab is rude
Takes advantage of his position to convey left-wing messages to his students.
Takes advantage of the fact that the parents will refrain from responding in order not to harm the future of their children.
My son has been in Reali Haifa for 6 years
I am disappointed with the school in general (except for the teacher Regina) and this principal in particular.
Yes, they will be few
Why doesn't the teachers' organization replace the "old man" he is 80 years old! Let's hold on to the funds of the altar, your time has already passed, make your way!
Kudos to manager Mandy. Finally someone who also thinks about the students' welfare and not just about personal interests!
In general, there should be a revolution in education in Israel.
It is not possible for the Histadrut, which is a body that was relevant to the last century, to threaten an entire country, and in the bottom line, it is responsible for lowering the quality of education in the country!!
Canceling my membership in the organization. An organization that silences other voices and harms students does not deserve for me to stay in it. The time has come to establish an alternative and valuable organization.
well done!
Well done Mandy. Senpsop sounds the logic of the thinking person and not the herdsmanship of the H,H, teachers. And I call us that because I also teach and lead like a donkey in a herd. Those of us who are interested in raising critical, conscientious, and valuable students flow with the herd even though we think otherwise. And depriving all of our children. The time has come for value and inventive and value thinking to raise its head. strength Who needs a teacher's organization that operates in adria and contains all creativity and criticism. The teachers' organization has long been elevated in its position. Fire Ran Erez immediately. The time has come for reorganization and rewriting of the organization's values. strength The time has come for the teachers to serve as an example to the students of how to think critically, creatively and ethically. strength I wish many of them would follow in your footsteps and stop being herdsmen.
Ram Erez lost the cob on him... Congratulations that the students were not hurt...
The teachers' organization is sabotaging the teachers. The teachers' salaries with or without an agreement are significantly low. The policies of this failed organization should not be agreed to. Kudos to the Reali manager for his approach against the faltering organization that only hurts high school teachers.
Why was Mandy removed? Good morning and welcome to everyone
Ran Erez's supporters are unsuccessful teachers who, if not for Erez, would have been fired a long time ago. In fact, the teachers' organization takes care of the failed teachers because the successful ones were employees under personal contract with much better conditions. This is Erez's power and it's time to stop.
Teachers are paid more than other sectors.
Look at the ultra-Orthodox and the Ebrachs who are always taken care of and want to lower their salaries.
They are also teachers and receive less than the teachers of Ran Erez
They don't publish anything against Rabinovitch here. Trending newspaper
The stupidity of this Rabinovitch is unbelievable. gnaws at the legs of the tree on which he sits. The chauvinist Smotrich wants to cut the salaries of the teachers who bring home a "second salary", and especially wants to break up the union through personal contracts - so that he can send home whoever he wants and lower salaries and do whatever he wants with the teachers. If Ran Erez doesn't apply pressure - who will Will he be kept when they want to fire him for liberalism and open discussions in the classroom?
Kudos to the director of Reali, who puts the mental well-being of his students first in his eyes.
I support the cause that took the students on the trip, he is not a puppet and he also has my judgment sounds reasonable and more than that is right.
I read the article and the verdict. I was abroad for more than 20 years, a teacher, the vice principal of a school with more than 3000 students and about 300 employees. This organization is a good concept, although no one thought about students. A school principal is right, he is a manager and a manager and must accept Decisions for the benefit of the students only. I was also a member of an organization here in Israel, I didn't understand anything about teaching, or what it means to imitate grades. The students are alive. After 27 years, it's time to replace him. In the country of too many courts, are there also administrators, they are responsible for the level of the school. Go ahead, Mandy, keep thinking for the benefit and not for the politicians
Tired of the teachers' incessant whining and strikes! Their conditions are much better than other sectors of the economy that work just as hard! Salaries improve with seniority, they have training rewards, a year off and many holidays. The difference is that they control the parents and therefore it is easy for them to strike. Every year!! This is completely overkill!
Kudos to the teacher who truly cares about the mental well-being of his students and takes them on a trip that raises their morale and connects them to the landscapes of the country and contributes to resilience and social cohesion, without referring to the unnecessary restrictions of the teachers' organization under the authority of Ran Erez, who should go home already!
Aim for Principal Mandy Rabinovitch for independent thinking and for the good of the students!
The most failed body in the country is the education system. They have the largest budget in the country with the worst achievements. This system should be privatized one hour earlier
Mandy Rabinowitz sees the best interests of the students, unlike Ran Erez. Such heartlessness in such a complex time for our children, and in the year when they are supposed to mobilize and give their lives for the country. Well done Mandy, don't be sorry. You did the right thing!
Ran Erez Gangster
Good luck Mr. Rabinovitch. I wish all managers behaved like you! We are educators and the children are of utmost importance. Ren Erez is the one who needs to be removed and beautiful one hour before
Ran Erez, he is the one who must fly and beautiful one hour earlier!
Hanan Erez, the chairman of the teachers' organization, is the one who should fly to hell!
The fact that Ran Erez is a bully is indisputable.
But... and there is a very big but... a large part of the team of teachers headed by Mr. Rabinovitz are themselves members of the organization and do not wish to violate the sanctions and oppose the populist moves of Mr. Rabinovitz who chooses to behave as a thug as well.
In addition, it is interesting to know that Mr. Rabinowitz himself was on the verge of being fired from the school and there he knew very well to use the services of the organization he did not want to belong to.
Perhaps Mr. Rabinovitz is bumping into Beren Erez because he is actually a small-time politician who wants to replace him in his position? This will bring him into the spotlight in meetings with the Minister of Finance, the Minister of Education, media interviews, etc.
interesting.
Mandy, I wish you were my manager. Ran Erez should vacate his place long ago...
does more harm than good.
The teachers' organization was established at the time because of the enthusiasm of the teachers' union at the blessed initiative of a number of high school teachers. It seems to me that the time has come once again to remove the current chairman or to set up a competing organization that will be concerned with the welfare of the students and not the personal prestige of its leaders. By the way, it seems to me that Ran Erez has not seen students for quite a few years, and it is very difficult for me to understand how the teachers allow themselves to be led by A person who forgot how to stand in front of students...
Mandy conveys one clear message... education is not a factory where an assembly line is stopped.
Those who chose to engage in teaching and education chose ideology... in spirit and not in matter.
As parents give up for the sake of children, so educators come to inaugurate to serve a noble cause... It is true that they deserve perhaps much more... But when there is a connection to an organization that has not been able to achieve its goals and improve its conditions in a way that does not harm our students, our children, then it should reconsider its course.
Mandy well done!! I am the mother of a crying 11th grader who really needs the grades in order to examine the continuation of the reserve and it is bothering him.
A managing king with a human background. Erez should go home, he is tired of him, a man of quarrels and condemnation
I do not agree with Mr. Rabinowitz at all.
Mainly with his 2 central statements:
1. "My argument is that there should be proportionality"
2. "It is not possible that those who suffer are only the students"
Before you attack Mr. Cedar:
What is a proportional strike in your eyes? Give a practical alternative, just complaining about those holding the reins doesn't help anyone.
Only the students suffer? What about the teachers who have families whose salary is stuck somewhere in the past in a time when all the prices are just going up all the time?
Kudos to Mandy Rabinowitz,
The time has come for Ran Erez to finish his position and let someone worthy manage the teachers' organization
Ran Erez died after 27 years. to you.
This is how it should be done and done by all those who consider themselves educators.
Oh well done
Finally a strong manager who cares about the children and not the ego of the chairman of the old organization
He deserves a TLS
Kudos to the high school principal Mandy Rabinovitch.
The man in the group.
Continue like this and work for the benefit of the students and not on the backs of the students, as the small political businessman works, who should have retired a long time ago.
that's how it is
When you mix politics, Histadrut in education.
Mandy is a manager, educator, life teacher,
And you deal with small things
Because of Ran Erez, who disables trips and joys for students in this difficult year.
I don't know Mandy, but it seems to me that in any case it is better not to be part of this disgusting organization.
I wonder why it was removed interesting ???
My late grandmother Rachel used to say
there is no smoke without fire!!!
It's a good thing that grandma is already dead so she won't hear your tongue musings.
Bull's Eye
That's how it is when someone is in office for too long. I think he is allowed everything. That the students won't enlist, that they won't be able to go to the reserve... nothing interests him. Not ready for the streamlining of teachers that good teachers will get more than bad ones like in any other sector. It's a mafia and not a teachers' organization
Ran Erez is a neighborhood thug who has nothing to do with education. Learning from the Prime Minister to take care only of himself. On the other hand, Mandy Rabinowitz is a super educational figure. I regretted that he returned to run for the position of mayor of Haifa. Pride to Mandy Rabinowitz, who was removed from the teachers' organization. It is beneath his honor to be in an organization run by Ran Erez. He and a beautiful cousin are a greedy couple with bullying and rudeness and this is the level of teachers.
Well done to Mandy.
Teacher for life.
Educator above all else.
A principal who prefers student happiness
approves advertising in the teachers' organization, sabbaticals, etc.
Enjoy.
Take care of yourself.
All the best to Mandy Rabinowitz
Great!
It's time to stop
with the threats of the Histadrut
Red Haifa
ended 50 years ago
On behalf of all graduates of the Real School
We support their generations
Dear Mandy Rabinowitz
rise and succeed