Banner Gordon 240624
Carmel Castle banner
Economic company banner 100724
Wide sea front banner
Haifa museums banner 081024
General banner 050924
Haifa museums banner 081024
Banner Kiryat Bialik Happy New Year 031024
Banner Kiryat Ata 011024
General banner 050924
Live advertising - wide - animated

One building in Hadar Carmel • Baha'i initiative, Templar planning and Jewish preservation

In Hadar, on Halutz Street 20, on the corner of Halutz and Brevold streets, located...

Percy Jackson: "Harry Potter is like having a genre named after him and Reardan brings up and compares."

In the hours after the 'earthquake', when we debated whether to go out on the street...

The public of reserve servants bears the burden of the war in an intense and significant way

This community of mature people who are in the peak years of their lives,...

Skirmish in the Olive Valley • A short story

Ways of life in the olden days. long ago! The group that arranged a reception for me...

Mandy Rabinovitch, the director of the Beit Biram school in Haifa, was expelled from the teachers' union

(live here in education) - The tribunal of the teachers' organization determined in a reasoned verdict, that the principal of Harieli's Beit Biram high school, Mandy Rabinovitch, will be removed from the teachers' organization for 8 years, of which 5 will actually be. According to Bin Hadin, Rabinovitch violated the organization's instructions when he issued trips contrary to the sanctions announced by the organization. Rabinovitch, for his part, stands behind his choice, claiming that in such a complex year, students should not be prevented from going on trips, adding that he is not bothered by the exclusion.


The chairman of the teachers' organization, Ran Erez, explains in the letter dealing with the handover of shield marks (dated 11/07/24) the need for sanctions by the teachers' organization:

"For two years we have been working without a collective agreement to improve our wages and working conditions. The Ministry of Finance is presenting a signing of a collective agreement by agreeing to personal contracts for teachers and administrators, while harming the rights of teachers and administrators and organized work, as well as harming social solidarity and the economic and occupational security of all of us...

It is very serious that a public of administrators and teachers are trying to please their employers and cooperate with them while seriously harming the solidarity and rights of teachers and administrators by way of a deliberate violation of the organization's instructions when it comes to carrying out the sanctions...

The struggle we are now waging is done in order to prevent salary deductions from you and to reduce as much as possible the harm to the students. A strike is easier to manage, but it hurts both teachers and students, and so far we have been careful not to do so, especially given the cliff of times.

The violation of the sanctions by administrators and teachers has the effect of strengthening the employers and the ministries of finance and education when the only pressure left on them is greatly weakened. This directly harms the interest of the teachers and administrators and weakens the organizational power that is meant to protect everyone."

The chairman of the teachers' organization Ran Erez (photo: the teachers' organization)
The chairman of the teachers' organization Ran Erez (photo: the teachers' organization)

Requirement to sign an employment agreement with the Treasury

The teachers' sanctions include school activities until 15:30 p.m. only and in addition grades are not published. The intention behind the sanctions is to get the Ministry of Finance to sign an employment agreement with the teachers of the teachers' organization, when the teachers are currently working without an agreement.

Contrary to Erez's claim that the purpose of the sanctions is to protect the teachers, and this while trying to reduce the harm to the students (for this reason it was also decided not to hold a full strike), Rabinovitch claims that the sanctions are disproportionate and only the students suffer from it.

"Fear of foreign considerations"

"The teachers' organization is led by a figure who does not serve it and harms the teachers," he claims Mandy Rabinovitch. "Teachers in the State of Israel deserve a different character, who will bring achievements. I'm not saying that the struggle is not important, that's another discussion. My argument is that there should be proportionality. It's not possible that only the students are the ones who suffer. In such a difficult year, it doesn't make sense to cancel an annual trip, certainly not It is possible that some schools received the approval for the trip and some did not, and this when there is no transparency in the matter. The schools that received a negative answer from the exception committee and could not go on an annual trip, did not receive any explanation for the decision, so there is a concern that foreign considerations are involved."

"Erez refused to withdraw"

"After the trip was already postponed from November and the trip to Poland was canceled as well, the demand of the 12th grade students and parents was to go on the trip," says Rabinovitch. "I asked Maren Erez to make an exception, personally. These are children who have gone through corona and war, so it is clear to any reasonable person that they must go on a journey, but Erez decided not to go back on his decision.

The parents, along with the teachers, the GNA instructors, and the members of the teachers' union, demanded that the trip be canceled, and so we did. On the last day of the trip, Erez sent me the lawsuit. In the court, I said that I did not violate the terms of the sanctions. If the teachers who went out are teachers of the Histadrut, we also took out the 10th grade campaign, it also went out only with the Histadrut employees."

"The teachers' organization sabotages education"

"It was decided to remove me from the teachers' organization, but I already said there that I am not interested in being part of a teachers' organization that makes wrong and unethical decisions. The instruction not to take the trips is an illegal educational instruction, which a black flag wavers over, therefore it should not be carried out. I was also not willing to hold the graduation parties.

The teachers' organization today sabotages education and does not help its teachers. We tried to convince Ran Erez to approve giving grades in math and English and not to "burn" the students' freedom, so that they would have to study for the high school diploma while they might have gotten a good grade. We received a snarky and sarcastic reply letter, which treated the children's time as if it didn't count and nothing would happen if children studied for matriculation even though they had already received a good grade.

Erez said that he is allowing the scores to be released because I want to put pressure on the Ministry of Defense, because a situation will arise where 12th grade students will not be able to enlist because they will be busy improving matriculation, and thus the Ministry of Defense will put pressure on the Ministry of Finance. Everyone is harmed and all means are kosher.

Rabinovitch adds: "Ran Erez should vacate his place after 27 years as chairman of the teachers' organization. We tried to convince those who could, that the grades must be released to the students, and we failed. We have no one to talk to.

All the managers talk to him, and he doesn't listen to anyone. Tens of thousands of teachers eventually decided to transfer the grades to the students, and voted a vote of no confidence in Baran Erez.

Because of the intimidation of the teachers' organization, there are teachers who did not pass the grades and their students do not know what the shield and matriculation grades are. Some of the students will not pass the matriculation exam in the second year, because they do not have the strength to pass after this year and when they find out that they received bad grades, they will no longer have a way to correct them."

"Harming the students is immoral, especially in a year like this. They also hurt the teachers and the status of the teacher. The bullies create a conflict between teachers, parents and students. We, the administrators, absorb the fire from everyone. We tried to convince Erez to go back on the decision not to release the grades. The 2nd year deadline in Aglit is already lost , there is only a sophomore year left in math. This person is busy chasing a school principal to make a move on me and the reali and prove that he is strong, when it falls apart in his hands he needs to do two things today: release the grades and let someone else fill the position and get an agreement "

"Erez came uninvited to our teachers' room. They told him, how do you do it in a year like this, and he said in our teachers' room, that the war ended a long time ago. History will not forget the one who only tried to promote his sector and in the end only hurt him. 27 years is more every".

Today on B network Ran Erez bitter that teachers should not be under pressure because they are also mothers and wives. "The statement that Ran Erez said online today proves more than anything who we are dealing with, not only a man who is heartless towards the students but also misogynistic and hurts his teachers without even blinking an eye."

The tribunal of the teachers' organization: "It is impossible for Rabinowitz to violate the sanctions, when the teachers' organization acted in his favor two years ago"

The tribunal of the teachers' organization discussed the petition against Rabinovitch, when in the hearing Erez explained that the petition was filed after Rabinovitch took the 11th and 12th grades out for annual trips. Rabinovitch asked to postpone the hearing on the petition, and during the postponement he took out another layer for the trip - the 10th layer.

In the discussion, Erez pointed out that in recent years the teachers' organization helped the Reali school when it was in financial distress, and with the help of the organization, the school signed a new collective agreement. In addition, Erez claimed that the organization also helped Rabinovich personally, when two years ago he was on the verge of being fired and with the help of the organization this was avoided.

Erez claimed, and the court agreed with the claim, that it is unthinkable that the teachers' organization would help the members of the organization when they need help, but when the teachers' organization announces sanctions to protect the working conditions of the teachers, the members of the organization will refuse to cooperate with it.

The court ruled that Rabinovitch violated the instructions of the teachers' organization:

According to the sanctions, the organization's teachers' school day will end at 15:30 p.m., so that trips of more than one day will take place after receiving approval from the organization's Exceptions Committee. Rabinovitch authorized the study levels at the school to go on a trip one after the other. Regarding the 3th layer, Rabinovitch claimed in the court that it was an educator who took his class on a 15-day trip, meaning that it was the educator's decision. The court rejected the claim. Regarding the 30th layer, the court stated that no explanation was given regarding the decision to take her on a trip Regarding the twelfth grade, Rabinovich claimed that he instructed the teachers to sit in the hotel rooms from XNUMX:XNUMX p.m., or to return to their homes and arrive again the next day, and in any case, he claimed, they were not members of the organization.

The court rejected the claim stating that the school principals are supposed to help the organization with the sanctions and not sabotage them by using teachers who are members of the Histadrut. The court also firmly rejected Rabinovitch's claim that it was an illegal instruction.

According to the court, it is not possible for a manager or teacher to decide on his own which instruction to accept and which not to accept. In addition, it is claimed that Rabinovitch did not contact the teachers' organization in writing before leaving for the trip with the claim that in his opinion it was illegal teaching. At the same time, the court noted that the pressures placed on a school principal regarding the 12th grade trip are understandable, and this is exactly why the Exceptions Committee exists.

The ruling also stated that a member of an organization has a duty to obey the organization's instructions in any case, and especially in cases of sanctions, and that the strength of the teachers' organization stems from the fact that behind it are members who stand with it in every struggle it leads, and there cannot be a situation where the organization is trying to act on behalf of the teachers and they do not share with it action.

The verdict will hang in the teachers' room

In the verdict, it was determined, as mentioned, that Rabinowitz leaves and is removed from his membership in the organization for a period of 8 years, 5 years of actual removal and 3 years of probation.

The meaning of the conditional suspension for 3 years is that if Rabinovitch violates the instructions of the teachers' organization during the next two years, he will be suspended for another 3 years beyond the stipulated 5. In addition, the anonymous verdict will be published on the organization's website and in Bitown, and will also be posted on the bulletin board in the teachers' room at Beit Biram.

contact: At watsapBy email

Michal Grover
Michal Grover
Michal Grover Education reporter • Real estate • Company Contact: 054-4423911 Mail to the container: [email protected]

Articles related to this topic

104 תגובות

  1. The obvious conclusion is that the private schools should be excluded from the teachers' organizations.
    The teachers in them earn much higher sums than in the state education, they have nothing in common with the struggles of the teachers in the state education, they have no desire for solidarity with those who earn much less than them.
    They just want to dance at both weddings: both to be far beyond the conditions of their fellow organizations and to be entitled to the benefits and additional conditions that the organizations obtain.
    In this state of affairs, when there is no solidarity, the right thing is to remove the private schools completely from the teachers' organizations and establish a private school teachers' organization.

  2. A man among men. Does the teachers' organization have a court? What is the fourth authority? And the chairman of the organization, the king of Hungary? What nonsense. The schools will disappear soon, along with all the archaic dictators who hold them as private property.

  3. What is this tyranny? A manager who works for the benefit of the students and refuses to obey a mafia and corrupt organization will be tried in the organization's court!!! which is one hundred percent subordinate to Ran Erez the dictator and was punished. That's how it is here that those who work for the common good are punished and those who think of their own good first. Illusory country.

  4. In these difficult days of lack of routine! You should congratulate a person who keeps the routine as in all the programs on television that continue in entertainment programs despite the difficulty and sorrow for the abductees
    It is very petty to descend into the lives of students and teachers and administrators!
    It's a shame that they exercise power in unethical ways and do not solve problems with the participation of the entire HMM education team of parents and students!
    We haven't grown up yet! In addition, in my opinion, 27 years in this organization is already longer than Bibi

  5. All the best to him. A person with values ​​who acts according to the circumstances. You have to put everything aside. Challenging period. A holocaust has passed us by and it is not over yet. Ran Erez acts with a lack of national public responsibility.

  6. He is right! Politics stinks on the backs of the children. How many have suffered in Corona, this terrible period will carry with them for a whole life, disconnection from family and friends, for such a long period and until we have already passed this nightmare they are prevented from traveling, because of politics? disgrace!

    Blessings to you, dear person!

  7. All the best to him. One principal who cares enough about the students to fight these stupid sanctions. How can you expect all the teachers in the country to turn a blind eye to continuous harm to students?

  8. The most champion manager in the world
    I had the privilege of being educated by him in youth Hadassah, and he is truly my neighbor and uplifter, seeing the good of the students and the teachers alike.
    He flew with us on a trip to Poland about 15 years ago and left us with a unique experience of what our people and country are.
    Rest in peace, he knows what he's doing. Well done Mandy Rabinovitch, the students, parents and teachers are with you

    • Only such people know what the people are and what the state is, which was declared and should be. Not what all the criminals who own it and turned it into a criminal organization say and do. Including the king of Hungary who behaves like a communist leader in the days of Stalin.

  9. Mandy hopes you will see my response, saying here on behalf of all the students in Reali: Well done to you!
    This is how you should behave in the face of the despicable behavior of the teachers' organization and its disgraceful sanctions, God bless 💪

  10. Shame that a person of Ben Gurion's age still manages the Ministry of Education. Ran Erez, retire, you are unnecessary.

  11. Good luck, where are there other people like this, the welfare of the students above all else, very proud of you, not to give in to these evil dreamers. Who decided that the war was over a long time ago?? While we were building at the front ?? evil

    • There is no way to lead without a certain amount of pride and since you have to face a criminal organization every day, it will always be perceived as arrogance by someone. Courage and doing the right thing should be done at any reasonable cost, even at the cost of arrogance.

  12. I wish all school principals would put the welfare of the students first. They will recognize their struggles, support them and want their success. It is gratifying to see a manager who knows what the correct order of priorities is and acts accordingly.

  13. Children do not have matriculation grades before enlistment. There are deadlines but no grades, all in all it makes sense. Children are not taken on trips. Who will we fight Mr. Erez? Who exactly is he punishing? Maybe he expects the parents, some of whom are fighting for the existence of the state, to fight for him? Ran Eps

  14. The teachers' organization crossed all limits!!!
    Just insolence!
    The teachers in Israel are paid among the highest in the world (there are so many studies and articles on this...) and so many benefits with all the Jewish holidays that it's just cheeky!

    You need to switch to a personal contract.
    A teacher who does not bring grades and educational achievements - leaves the system. A teacher who stays for many years and does not change the ways of learning or working with the children - will be removed from the system!!!!

    We all work in the economy
    We measure every day what our achievement is and what is not
    The sword of dismissal is present every day on us if we decide not to work but only "come to work" (like most of the teachers I have known in my life) and yes - we really do not receive a salary increase or bonuses every year.
    Also in high-tech. Even in huge international organizations in general that have run into difficulties.

    So what?
    Are you on strike?
    Do you call the customers and inform them that we will not transfer the software version or that we will not send the equipment as promised?
    Really really not!!!

    The time has come for the state to arrest all the directors of the teachers' organization and the big criminal Ran Erez. It is amazing how this man has destroyed generations of students. Just catch and catch the students.

    disgusting!!!!
    The labor courts must wake up and judge him.

  15. The decision of the disciplinary court of the teachers' organization is not admissible as evidence in court. This is the law in the law of evidence.

  16. When the bakery goes wild it is located. Respect to you, dear manager, for not giving in to the whims of a worker leader who takes "pedagogical" steps and harnesses the court for this purpose.
    The rampage of the pseudo-leader deserves to be stopped and removed from your neck and the necks of teachers and students alike. Successfully!!!

  17. Kudos to the real manager.
    The teachers' organization headed by Ran Erez needs to replace its head with someone young and energetic instead of the pensioner who has served for over twenty years
    as the head of the organization.

  18. Kudos to the school principal.
    During all my years of teaching, I was disturbed by the willingness of the teachers' organization to strike and take sanctions, on the backs of the students, in general - and sometimes especially hard.
    This is a year of war, very difficult for students, parents and teams. Do not add to the harm to the students at such a time.

  19. Ran Erez is many years past retirement age, it does not make sense for him to head a workers' organization, it is unlikely that such an important organization would be governed by an election system that is not democratic. The organization does not find the strength to obtain conditions for its members for reasons that are not clear, someone checked the insurance policy of its members The organization compared to organizations of other sectors, it's time to refresh and replace and it's good one hour earlier

  20. This manager is an example. I am so happy that there is someone like him in the rotten education system. A few more of these and I'll be a teacher.
    Well done, admire you, no less.

  21. Wow, what a tremendous achievement for Ran Ers. He should resign immediately. This is a person who has been causing irreparable damage to teachers in Israel for decades and no one takes this 0 seriously. 79 years old, with a number of teachers who "run away" in the Ceausescu-style elections, who benefit from the money that this unnecessary organization collects from the city for a piece of brochure they receive once a month and which is immediately thrown in the trash + money that the teachers pay themselves in order to finance their own annual gifts. The "goose without reward" reform is one of the most delusional things that the education system in Israel has ever seen and caused thousands of teachers to retire and are still retiring from the system, when it is clear to them that their salary will be below all criticism. Ran is a powerful man and no one treats him anymore. He leaves behind him A bad, repulsive and disgusting legacy. Well done to you! Go with your truth, because when someone needs the help of this organization in a certain problem, he can only dream of it from bitter experience with them - I am sick of this wrong thing.

  22. Hope this is the beginning of the end of the misogynistic and arrogant Ran Erez and of the corrupt and depraved teachers' organization in its current form

    Maybe it's time to establish a parallel organization? I'm sure that "Employee Power" will be happy to help

    Especially proud as a Reali graduate

  23. I also think that there is a limit to the abuse of students who have experienced corona, wars... so you should give them memories of a party trip and of course grades

  24. Kudos to the moral director responsible for the well-being of his students!!
    The organization has long since not acted in the best interest of its members and certainly does not see and feel the students that the shooters are supposed to serve
    Ran Erez Biryon, the antithesis of an educator does not remember ever being a teacher (for gymnastics!!)

  25. Kudos to Director Rabinowitz. Does what is right without fear and calculation because he thinks about his students. Ren Erez the little politician is good at flexing his muscles and using his power. A small politrock

  26. Good for you! The teachers' organization is a powerful organization on the verge of being dictatorial. Ran Erez was not chosen by the teachers!!! They are not concerned about the state of education or real improvement for teachers. It's all politics.

  27. The students whose studies have already suffered so much in the Corona years and then in the October 23 war really do not deserve to have grades hidden from them now. You have to be a bad person, yes, just bad-hearted, to come to such a decision. There is a limit to every trick and every abuse. Those who do not understand this should learn a lesson the hard way: teachers and administrators will not obey these inhuman orders, and will find other ways and other leaders to conduct their righteous struggle.

  28. The students whose studies have already suffered so much in the Corona years and then in the October 23 war really do not deserve to have grades hidden from them now. You have to be a bad person, yes, just bad-hearted, to come to such a decision. There is a limit to every trick and every abuse. Those who do not understand this need to learn a lesson the hard way: teachers and administrators will not obey these inhuman orders, and will find other ways and other leaders to conduct their righteous struggle.

  29. Ran Erez was a physical education teacher in Ashdod, with a part-time job who, according to rumors, was not really careful about attendance
    For many years, at least two decades, the man has not taught...
    The fact that Ran Erez represents a group of teachers who teach elementary school, all of whom have advanced degrees including a master's degree for professionals and this high-quality group is represented by Ran Erez is a shame and disgrace!!!
    Teachers get out of indifference, next time there are elections go vote and kick this person to hell

  30. I am proud of the principal whose students are more important to him in such a crazy time. I am a grandmother of 7 grandchildren and I am pained by the Ministry of Education's abuse of them in such a crazy time. The Minister of Education and his entire staff are a shame to the country. How do the children of evacuees have a head for matriculation exams? I speak from my heart. Forty years a teacher in the education system. The student was always at the center and through my initiation was a function of the student's character and ability. So good luck to Mr. Mandelwitz. Well done.

  31. He loses nothing. This organization was a friend of his time and with him Ran Erez.
    Due to the theft of a credit card, they did not transfer a standing order to the organization. The secretary of the Jerusalem branch claims she sent me an email that I didn't receive and I didn't respond. Hello, there is a phone and it is paid for by the members' money!!!! So she removed me from the Igon. I contacted Ran Erez and even a confirmation of receiving a referral did not arrive. Simply an organization that is not an organization and has undeserving officials. Learned from the Knesset.

  32. Align power
    There is no reason to harm students who are hostages every time
    There is another way to get results

  33. An excellent decision, Director Bays cannot use his influence to harm the organization that protects the rights of teachers....Thus he becomes a member of those who despise the public of teachers in the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Education

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Good time: Dia Saba was invited to the Israeli national team • Dean David was also invited again

In a week, the Israeli national team will step on the grass at the "Stade de France" stadium in the hope of stunning and getting some first points in the "League of Nations" campaign against France, before...

The prestigious leadership program has been successfully completed

Mayor Kiryat Bialik and the senior team have successfully completed the prestigious Bloomberg-Segol Leadership Program. The mayor of Kiryat Bialik, Eli Dukorski, together with the director general of the municipality Lior...

Hundreds of Rafael employees were vaccinated by Klalit employees against the flu at their place of work

Hundreds of Rafael employees, who work around the clock to support the war effort and national security, were vaccinated against the flu at their workplace. As part of the preparation for the winter season, Klalit completed an operation...

At the time of the missiles - Klalit's brother and sister store patients in their homes in the north

In the midst of the flu season and under a continuous security threat, the teams of brothers and sisters of Klalit in the Haifa district and the Western Galilee are engaged in an important task: protecting the health of the residents...

The plan to expand Kiryat Bialik was approved

The Haifa District Planning and Construction Committee approved for deposit the supplementary plan for the expansion of the Kiryat Bialik industrial area - employment and commercial areas will be expanded following the burial of power lines...