Beit Mainz in the center of Carmel: 7 years of closure

Between Panorama Hotel and Nof Hotel, at 103 Hanasi Boulevard,...

Defense instructions - Home Front Command - from Saturday 12/10/24 at 20:00 until Monday, 14/10/24 at 20:00

(Lives here in the Home Front) - The Home Front Command updates the residents of...

Summary of the Kippur events in the various sectors - 12/10/24

(Live here) - While you were fasting, several things happened in the field....

Safety deficiencies on the beach promenade in Haifa cause passers-by to trip and get injured

(Hai Pa) - Residents demand from the municipality immediate treatment of hazards...
General banner 050924
Haifa museums banner 081024
Hand banner for a friend - wide
Wide sea front banner
Carmel Castle banner
Banner Gordon 240624
Economic company banner 100724
Banner Kiryat Ata 011024
General banner 050924
Live advertising - wide - animated
Haifa museums banner 081024
Banner Kiryat Bialik Happy New Year 031024

A big small museum - the museum of models and miniatures in Haifa

The Museum of Models and Miniatures - a pleasant surprise.

Light fasting - the main benefits of fasting for the body and mind

Many experts claim that fasting, for periods of time, benefits the body...

How does the "situation" affect you? • The personal changes and intimacy during wartime

The tense security situation leads many to introspection and reevaluation...

Beit Mainz in the center of Carmel: 7 years of closure

Between Panorama Hotel and Nof Hotel, at 103 Hanasi Boulevard,...

Years of suffering have come to an end: "The homeless have completely disrupted our lives"

(haipo) - Years of struggle, mental suffering, fears and despair, which were also accompanied by endless financial expenses, have finally come to an end. Against the homeless man who made the lives of the tenants at 16 Azar St. in Haifa, a removal order was issued by the court and he was removed from the place by the police.


In 2021, as I recall, an article was published in Hai Fe, which described the ongoing suffering of the residents of the building at 16 Azar St. in Haifa, which was caused by a homeless person taking over the area of ​​the floor below the building. But nothing helped. Over time, the homeless man took over more and more of the place, when he connected to the electricity network and used the building's water. So, in addition to the trouble he caused them, the tenants also found themselves having to pay for the use of the building's resources.

Just yesterday (Sun. 1/7/24) an article was published in Chai Pa telling about the confrontation of residents on Degania Street in Kiryat Haim, with the constant presence of a homeless man who settled on one of the benches in the street. They describe the sanitary hazard created around him, the bad smells and the rude behavior, which includes cursing and shouting, defecating in front of everyone and above all they tell about the helplessness in trying to find a solution.

In the article they tell about the suffering that spread over a period of about a year, while they want to point out again and again that they do not want the man to get hurt, but only that he find the best solution for them and for him.


The appearance of the building in Haifa that was taken over by Der-Rehov - Homeless (photo: Chai Pe in the field)
The appearance of the building in Haifa that was taken over by Der-Rehov - Homeless (photo: Chai Pe in the field)

"We lived in fear"

And back to 16 Azar St. One of the tenants says in a conversation to Lai Fa:
"All these years we lived in fear, in frustration, with no quality of life. We were at a loss, we didn't know what to do. After all, we turned to all the relevant parties that are supposed to provide us with services and protection on the matter - the local authority and the police, but to no avail. They would shift the responsibility from one to the other and we stayed No answer. He would defecate in front of our eyes. He would collect lots of scraps and bring them to the building. He would always threaten to beat us And he would do all kinds of horrible things. Personally, I wasn't that moved by his threats, until one time he said he would pour acid on my face. Here I was already stopped and really started to fear and fear that he might carry out the threat."


The tenant continues: "Last month, all the tenants got together and decided that by this point, we had to do something. We hired the services of a lawyer and paid 8,000 NIS to have a removal order issued against him from a court. Fortunately, the court issued the order yesterday (Monday 30/6/24), the police arrived and evacuated him, we don't know where. I hope he doesn't come back. This whole situation caused us enormous mental damage, we were seriously hurt, it is a defect in our quality of life in every sense, our day to day, our privacy, our mental health. I think we will have to relearn to live life in a normal way."

The removal order issued to the homeless person

A toilet for the homeless in the courtyard of the building (photo: Hai Pa in the field)

The police informed me here:
"The issue of treating the homeless is the responsibility of the local authority."

The Haifa Municipality responded:
"The municipality of Haifa operates a unit to locate and treat street urchins. The unit's employees conduct proactive patrols in the city's neighborhoods to locate people living on the streets, on the beach, in public parks, and more.

The activity is carried out at all hours of the day and in collaboration with other care providers, with the aim of reaching all the street dwellers and convincing them to receive care that includes a roof over their heads, food, bathing and personal and social care.

However, treatment cannot be forced on a person against his will, and welfare workers do not have policing and enforcement powers. Therefore, in cases involving an invasion of one or another structure, when all efforts to persuade the social workers fail (as happened in this case as well), the treatment is transferred to the legal authorities, who have the authority to enforce the matter."

contact: At watsapBy email

Samar Odeh - Carantinji
Samar Odeh - Carantinji
Journalist in the team of correspondents of the Chai Pe site • Municipal reporter, crimes, environment and health Contact Samar by email: [email protected]

Articles related to this topic

28 תגובות

  1. In short, the judicial system is rotten, there is no reason why such a nuisance should not be thrown out on the same day. But this doesn't happen in the judges' houses, so what do they care about the garbage, that is, the ordinary citizens. Reform now!

  2. Let's call the baby by his name, unfortunately I notice that they turn the homeless into lepers, and they are just like me, and like you, the fact that they live on the street, without means, and without help, they chose that, but never judge them, because all the judge at the end of the day we will be judged,

  3. Stupid municipality, your job is to go to the court to remove the hazard and contact the police to enforce an exclusion order

  4. The downtown is collapsing with many homeless people, drug addicts, prostitutes, drug stations, crime families and associates. Really great city.

  5. I live in an adjoining building and I know this homeless person.
    This is a person who used a little water to wash his face in the morning! Because of little water, they turn to the court to issue an eviction order!
    Their punishment will come from above

    • Wow Ronnie what are you saying - so why not take it home if it's just some water. Another beautiful soul at the expense of others.

  6. I lived in the same building for over half a decade and I never saw any problems from that guy, except that he built a kind of tent-apartment for him under the building. If there were neighbors much more annoying and problematic than him.

    Another matter is that it connects piratedly to building resources and this is indeed a problem - both in terms of payment and in terms of safety. But still the feeling of intimidation that the article here creates is a bit unfair

  7. Hahaha this is Moshe Kof Kof we used to read as children and today I buy all kinds of things from him headphones and things but he is a great person you just have to know how to behave with him

  8. How does the municipality manipulate that they are righteous, they try, if they fail, it goes to the authority of the law hahahahaha.
    For years we complained and you did nothing. The apartments paid NIS 8000, so it went to the legal authority, give them back the money

  9. The municipality is only a hero against the pigs, killing them mercilessly. Why did the tenants need a lawyer to evict a street tenant? The problem will not be solved with a removal order.. he will find a new place.

  10. Two homeless people who invaded the place at least 4 years ago. One of them is the bearded drunk who collects alms at the traffic lights in Zio. Does the municipality care? Are the police responsible? Bullshit!!! Why do the tenants have to pay NIS 8000? These are people who invaded a private area and are harassing all the residents of the street. The police should have evicted them a long time ago. shame shame shame

  11. Bullshit!!! I am a street dweller and I am ready to receive any assistance from any source, but unfortunately no authority is willing to provide assistance, so I am forced to continue living on the street with all that implies

  12. In such a situation, the only solution is to contact the criminal elements to pay them a few dimes and they will make sure that he will not return there again.
    In Haifa there is no shortage of criminal organizations of one kind or another that would be happy to help

  13. The authorities are running out of hands. To collect property taxes champions. And if they don't pay straight execution. But to carry out their duties no and no. Shame

  14. A homeless man named Shmuel has lived at the Dor Alon gas station in the Haifa Mall for over 10 years, at least he is harmless. I'm just asking the welfare department in Haifa municipality and the social workers don't know the case!

  15. The municipality is weak 0 tolerance towards homeless people in the city we are fed up !!
    I'm also fed up with the garage in Kibbutz Galvoit 89 in the city of Nemassas, a dysfunctional municipality!

  16. The welfare department of the Haifa municipality did not provide the following message:
    "300 people in the welfare and social work departments are unable to do anything under any circumstances. However, we would like to inform you that dozens of workers have recently received upgrades to standards as well as vehicle expenses and an attached vehicle on behalf of the municipality so that they can
    Tour the neighborhoods, or go shopping for two hours, not even in the vicinity of the office, where many do not come at all due to pregnancy
    Then another pregnancy (3 years of work). It's none of your business, but we'll update you anyway, that only recently did we return all the office workers from my day
    Formation and important conferences on the subject of emergency nursing in two luxurious hotels in Eilat and for that thanks to the lovely municipality that showers us with more and more benefits. Regarding the homeless, it is required to file a complaint with the police. We are not nannies.

    • How much can be discredited. For your information, they cut down on personnel. Cliché cut. Literally one-third of the power of Lake Nadar and the idiot who will come to work in a difficult community full of oppressors and impoverished poor populations. There are absolutely no social workers. The conditions that were not accepted then, social workers went to work in private companies. You and everyone else complained that the workers travel, who in fact work go around to find homeless people and youth in need and do not sit in the office for home visits. You are dirty and cliché destruction in general, bad gossip and people who care about them, so dirty. The municipality once excelled, they received awards that the municipality is treated and we. Hat and what today will want garbage and garbage, no one wants to work for free, not even you.. how evil you are

  17. I heard a story, how a friend became a homeless person. I am telling this with the understanding of the angle and the point of view of street dwellers.

    The same friend, suffered from schizophrenia from the age of 30, and refused to take the medication prescribed for him by the psychiatrist for the reason that he saw the consumption of the psychiatric medication as an invasion of his privacy. The psychiatric drugs made him less happy, he said.

    He became a homeless person after all his credit cards were blocked due to debts, and when his wife issued a restraining order against him for three months because he wanted to have marital relations with her against her will.

    He was "kicked out" of a homeless shelter, after it was discovered that he was receiving a disability allowance of NIS 4500. From here, it was only a matter of time before he became the subject of an article like the one here.

    As the stay on the street lengthened, he got used to the conditions of this stay, and if it weren't for relatives helping him, and picking him up from the street, he wouldn't agree to receive help from anyone anymore, because of the habit.

    I would be happy to interview you here, and provide more details. The live system here has my email address.

    • Maybe you should be tied up like a prison cell.
      A person like you who advocates violence should be behind bars.

  18. Shame and shame on Haifa municipality. This is a mistake by the municipality. Mayor Kalish cut her municipal employees. And also the budget cuts. She was endlessly appealed to for budgetary support. The situation is serious, they told her, but as soon as the municipality ignores it, this is the result. The police also did not cooperate with the local residents who suffered. They should have sued the municipality because they couldn't live a normal life with a stranger trashing their house. Because of the abandonment that he lived in this way, he caused the place to be filled with polluted animals, rats, which cause infectious diseases, and Imamdar thus raised children in a polluted house. Apparently the residents of the house could not sue them because of a financial problem. It's really sad how they pulled and didn't take care of the homeless tenant. The police neglected it, so who could take care of it? Shame!

Leave a comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

All the articles are alive

Reporting medical incidents in Haifa during Yom Kippur • MDA

(Hai Fe) - The medics and paramedics of MDA provided medical treatment to 77 people in Haifa during Yom Kippur. MDA was informed that there were no injuries...

Road accident on Route 22 • Bar in the 20s in average condition

MDA informed Lahi Pa: On Saturday night, 12/10/24, at 20:40 p.m., a report was received at MDA's 101 hotline in the Carmel area about a traffic accident on Route 22 from the Ata interchange...

The firefighters worked to put out fires that broke out during Yom Kippur following the firing of rockets into the northern Kiryats

Firefighters and Rescue reported to Lahi Fe: During Yom Kippur, fire fighters operated at several scenes in the Zebulon region as a result of cross-border projectiles being fired from Lebanon, and this under the command of the shift commanders...

Defense instructions - Home Front Command - from Saturday 12/10/24 at 20:00 until Monday, 14/10/24 at 20:00

(Live here in the home front) - The Home Front Command is updating the residents of Israel on the self-defense instructions. The policy is in effect starting Saturday, October 12, 2024, at 20:00 p.m. until...

Dramatic rescue at the port of Haifa: a mechanic was saved thanks to quick action

(Hai Fe) - Today (Kippur, 12/10/24) at noon, an emergency occurred in the port of Haifa, when a 39-year-old mechanic on board the ship MSC ASLI was found missing...