A majority acquittal increases confidence that the prosecution did its job to the best of its abilities. The assertion that the confession given by Zadorov is "false confession" casts a negative light on the Israel Police.
The reasonable person asks himself why a person would confess to a murder he did not commit and how could he know all the details? After all, only the murderer can know them!
Why is this happening?
The murder of the late Tair Rada created fear and terror in the public and as a result a very heavy public pressure that requires a strong backbone and great professionalism of the commanders who are not "contractors of success at any cost".
When the attorney's office assigns an accompanying attorney, then he becomes an integral part of the investigation team and usually also the one who leads it. In this situation, the investigation is no longer independent and the prosecution's review of the evidence and its weight is also not without bias and influence.
Prejudice
Language difficulties create big gaps, so do mentality and prejudices, but to state that the motive for the murder was a cantor of "stinking Russians" seems far-fetched, and probably stems from cultural differences between lawyers and investigators.
Internal police supervision
When most of the commanders and the axis of command did not deal with investigations and/or intelligence, there is a clear tendency of commanders not to monitor, but to accept the decisions of the prosecutor's office and the investigators as the only truth, without "ifka matbara" or an alternative opinion.
Conviction of murder by confession
A conviction based on a confession of murder is known as the pitfall of investigations, insofar as it is not supported by "forensic" laboratory evidence. Zadorov's acquittal is due to the lack of laboratory evidence. As science advances, so does the gold standard in criminal proceedings. Attorney Yarom Halevi deserves to receive the outstanding attorney award of the Bar Association, as a sign and example for believing in the innocence of the client he represented and embarking with him on a journey to climb such a slippery wall.
Conviction to life imprisonment by majority vote
Sending a person to life imprisonment in a non-unanimous panel decision creates eternal doubt. In many countries there is an obligation for unanimous decisions, and I think that the threshold for life sentences must be unanimous: if there is any doubt, there is no doubt, because the public interest is to act in favor of the accused.
My heart goes out to Tair's mother and her family, who were actually left with a painful, mysterious and unsolved wound. A verdict of 704 pages is a certificate of honor for the judges of Israel who each wrote according to the dictates of their conscience.
Freedom Holiday
Zadorov is free subject to appeal. May those involved in investigations and prosecutions today learn the lessons, each in his own field.
On the contrary, the very permission proves the corruption and subjugation in the police and the prosecutor's office, there was a skilled detail that Roman did not know from the first moment - the cell phone and it was hidden from the judges
And Borovsky, whoever was photographed and recorded as a farmer does not deserve to be mayor
A victory of populism. An overwhelming majority of Zvorov's supporters have not read the court records (you can easily find them on the Internet, visible to all who are interested). At the start of the trial, Zadorov's relatives testified that he is a cruel and violent person. Conversations with Dubbed (I heard the recording in Russian) leave no room for doubt that Zadorov is a murderer who even planned to rape the girl. But because of the unprofessionalism of the police, because of technical problems, Zadorov is free and the enemies of Israel are celebrating
To die, how do you bring everything upside down according to what is convenient for you to see. .. I would be ashamed to write the poster about the Israeli public's trust in the judicial system. Everything is upside down!!!!!! hahahaha
Mr. Jacob Borovsky, everything you have written here proves that we must reform and deduct stables in the entire legal system in Israel!!!
Dina is just, the justice system needs to be reformed, the coalition or the government should appoint the judges, the government is honest and reliable (like a garbage can)
The family system...
What a trust, no one buys the fake sentences anymore, especially the top one
It's no secret that it smells like a big cover-up here with the help of the top attorney general
There were probably "good sons" who didn't want to harm their future and were comfortable blaming it on him
Something was strange right from the beginning of the whole story including all the evidence of what went on at the school
And somehow this whole issue disappeared...
Tair Rada remains a mystery Zodvorov is not the killer I wonder who the real killer of Tair Rada is
On the contrary. One should ask why the court did not demand all the materials from the prosecutor's office, why the investigators extorted a false confession from Zdorov, why they are forgiven for sending an innocent man to life imprisonment, why the prosecutor's office and the justice system do not have enough resources to allow them to delve into the findings. In practice, also from the reactions of professionals in the field, that the attorneys and judges are negligent because of the work load, and the distortion of the law is the result of a contemptuous attitude towards the freedom of weak people.
As Ilana Rada, who experienced the full severity of the situation, said:
The prosecutor's office behaves like a criminal gang.
For all the opponents of the legal reform, everything is fine and dandy until the wheels of legalization run over you or your loved one and you will be in a state of torture of justice and civil rights, only not for the victims or the guardians of the law..
The case is well remembered from all sides.
To seat a new immigrant from the Commonwealth of Nations
Not understanding the language, they accuse him of murder
The man is confused. 16 years in prison, will he believe in a court??,
the opposite is. Lucky someone took on a project
and recreated the case. great luck
that was released And the killer still lives a peaceful life.
I think the opposite of almost every line you wrote.
You did not address the disgraceful failure of the prosecution and Shai Nitzan - sewing a conviction 'at all costs' and not in the first act. What was the reason for their insistence and campaign of slander and persecution - in public! – Ugly of the pathology and evidence experts? Did they hide the killer, or were they just lazy to look for him?
In my opinion, the police were pressured by the prosecutor's office all along. Failures in gathering evidence, testimony, confession, resulted in shocking torture that the mind cannot bear.
Is it possible that the jury system is better and they are less biased than the judges?
- A friend from her is a friend, a friend does a favor to his friend the attorney.. A judge and his friend from the attorney's office close a case behind closed doors..
A verdict of 704 pages - a scandal in itself. Hassles and unnecessary things that in themselves constitute legal torture. Weren't they taught to be short and concise?
This is indeed an earthquake but not the first.
The judges refuse to listen to the criticism of the lawyers and public criticism.. The prosecutor's office with serial plea deals and here and there in indictments according to interests and chances of conviction "benefits" from the lack of trust of the majority of the public in Israel and those who defend it are its employees and their family and friends who embark on unfounded propaganda battles that "everything is fine, look in the direction Other".
Legal reform is indeed needed. Separation of the position of the attorney general from the prosecutor's office and the appointment of a general prosecutor as in the rest of the world. Prohibition of legal advisors in the Knesset in the government from being appointed to the Supreme Court. The mechanism of an investigating judge who will specialize in the type of crime. Appointing audit bodies with the length of sentences and the limitation of beggarization. more and more. It is not against the left and in favor of corruption. This is for justice and against an anti-democratic jurisprudence that along the way also harms the human rights of the victims and the destruction of national security through selective enforcement and running amok for show cases.
Zadorov was convicted by 7 judges and 3 judges acquitted him of guilt. Luckily for him 2 of them were in the upper hand by a small majority.
His acquittal says nothing about the truth. Like probably countless other trials, there is the legal truth and there is the factual truth that will always remain a mystery.
Zidorov's acquittal increases confidence in the justice system ??????????????? Under no circumstances does Zadorov's acquittal equal and require an indictment to the prosecutor's office!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The winning judges are from the private market
The judge who did not win is a graduate of the mafia attorney's office