A ticking bomb in the heart of the city • Does the electric vehicle yard pose a threat to Haifa residents?

(Hai Fa) – The issue of electric vehicle safety in Haifa has been raised...

Shrapnel from a missile strike • Tuesday 10:31 near Yodpat

(Live here) - At the missile launch event that took place today (Tuesday...

Fire on the Sea Road – 04:20 24/6/25

(Live here) - At 4:20! Black smoke rose in the morning...

Why we must complete the mission against Iran and cut off the head of the snake once and for all

In recent weeks, the conflict between Israel and Iran has reached a boiling point...

Graffiti, Gentrification and Broken Fingers

Art in the public space is defined as art that is accessible to everyone, without...

The new commercial center and the first public services building in Hadar Carmel

At the intersection of Herzl and Bialik streets lies an international-style commercial building,...

Flower of the week • Jaffa Salmon

Carmel presents us with flowers in all seasons. In this column...

While the world trembles: How to help children coping with fear during wartime

While adults follow updates and analyze the situation, children...

Klish divides Haifa into five parts • Commentary • Dr. Yariv Sagi

Instead of adding and multiplying - the mayor of Haifa subtracts and divides

One of the things that the current government in Haifa excels at is subtraction and division. The fact is, the recent decisions of Mayor Kalish apparently divide the city into five parts - unequal. Parts of Haifa are almost given as a gift to various interest groups, while other parts are designated for very specific purposes. This painful process is another step in the disintegration of the city of Haifa, which is changing from one big and strong city to a senseless federation. Within this federation, each part of the city is shaped with its captive population, with an agenda that distinguishes only it and above all with future planning that is completely disconnected from the other parts. 

1. The ATM neighborhoods on the Carmel

Haifa municipality makes the big money on the Carmel. It seems that the ridge neighborhoods receive a minimum of service along with a maximum of property taxes. And minimal investment in infrastructure alongside the expansion of TAMA projects and new and dense construction that knows no bounds. There is nothing to be done, the city needs construction fees and improvement levies otherwise it will starve to death. The increasing density on the ridge may not yet be felt in all the schools in the ATM neighborhoods, but there is no doubt that in the coming years The overcrowding figures in the classes will increase to around 30 students on average in the first grades. By the way, the schools in the other parts of the city will continue to be closed due to a lack of public interest. And what is the value for the resident in general? What is there to talk about. Parking problems that will only get worse, cracked roads, dried up traffic islands And fattened wild boars will decorate the public space for years to come, apparently.

The Carmel Center in Haifa (Photo: Yaron Karmi)
The Carmel Center in Haifa (Photo: Yaron Karmi)

2. The boundaries of the ultra-orthodox territory are redefined

After many years in which the ultra-Orthodox public was forced to shrink into the old and familiar complexes, the redemptive change came. Public buildings pass into the hands of the ultra-Orthodox public thanks to far-reaching political agreements, and thus the boundary stones of the ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods are pushed into new districts. The new ultra-orthodox city breaks out of the traditional areas into the center of Hadar HaCarmel, Neve Yosef, Neve Paz and Neve Shanan. Everything that was withheld from this population during the previous regime, it receives as a religion and right now and with compound interest. In addition, the influence of this community is also evident on the cultural events in the city, or rather on the nature and timing of these events.

Redemption Intersection Hapoel Arlozorov (Photo: Reuven Cohen)
Hapoel Hapoel Arlozorov Redemption Intersection (Photo: Reuven Cohen - Haifa Municipality)

3. The no-man's land in the west of the city - a reserve for contractors

The current government makes a cruel separation between areas where there is a demand for urban renewal (the ATM neighborhoods) and those where there is almost no chance that anything will happen in the coming years (the neighborhoods in the west of the city). And don't let the green-gray renewal plans fool you. These plans only seemingly give an excuse to the existing government not to do almost anything else in the western neighborhoods.

Renovate urban parks? For what, there is urban renewal. pave roads? For what, there is urban renewal. wait Maybe you will. And what about the German colony and the lower city? This is a problem.. these are places that commemorate the successes of previous governments. So instead of acknowledging the achievements and continuing to nurture them, they made some cosmetic changes to the port campus plans and emptied the German colony.  

Closed police point - Hanamal Street - Lower City (Photo: Yaron Karmi)
Closed police station - Hanamal Street - Lower City (Photo: Yaron Karmi)

4. The tycoon cities in the Gulf area

The defeat of the city of Haifa to the "port city" in the First Port War led to the transformation of the bay area into a huge container warehouse. In addition, considerable parts of the Kishon Park were lost in favor of additional container warehouses. But if that is not enough, then it seems that we are going to lose in the second port war as well.

What will we lose this time? The international airport will be remembered as a joke, the expansion of the mooring will become a joke and the sailing competitions in Kishon will sink into the pages of history. And if that's not enough, there is a very strong alliance between the "Port City" and the "Petrochemical City".

By the way, the city of petrochemicals also won a considerable chain of achievements against the shenanigans of the municipality of Haifa and it does not seem at all that the city of Haifa has any influence on it. These two cities of tycoons only recently had another significant achievement. Disruption of the vision of the innovation bay of the mayor of Haifa. Such an achievement ensures not only the survival of the tycoon cities, but also the strengthening of their alliance.

"Innovation Valley" - Shaar Hamfaretz - RMI program - to clean Haifa Bay - Israel Land Authority - 35
"Emek Innovation" - Shaar Hamfaretz - Rami program - to clean Haifa Bay - Israel Land Authority - 35

5. Kiryat Haim - far from the eye, far from the heart

The most natural thing is to establish Kiryat Haim-Kiryat Shmuel as autonomy under a real resident administration. But because this is the natural thing, of course this will not happen during the current period of government. What is expected to happen is that we will witness the continuation of the nerve-racking wait for the final disintegration of the technical road and the Julius Simon road. Only when these roads turn into sand and gravel will the residents of Kiryat Haim and Kiryat Shmuel be able to finally disconnect from Haifa. Not far today…

Residents at the conference presenting an urban renewal plan for Kiryat Haim (Photo: Yaron Karmi)
Will there be urban renewal? Residents at the conference presenting an urban renewal plan for Kiryat Haim (Photo: Yaron Karmi)

Haifa is on its way to becoming a republic

The road to hell is paved with good intentions. It could really be that the leadership of the city of Haifa has good intentions in all the moves they have made recently, but one cannot argue with the dismal results. The most difficult result is the breaking of the city into five separate territories. This move definitively illustrates the city's backwardness. Even in the past, the Carmel and Hadar neighborhoods were light years apart when only two thin roads connected them. Kiryat Haim was beyond the sand dunes of the bay and the refineries were just a view from the windows of the residents of Hadar Carmel. Somehow we're back at it, and for no good reason.

contact: At watsapBy email

Dr. Yariv Sagi
Dr. Yariv Sagi
Dr. Yariv Sagi Haifai: policy planning, political consulting and strategic planning in local authorities and third sector organizations lectures and leads workshops in the field of political psychology [email protected] • www.yarivsagi.com

Articles related to this topic

57 תגובות

  1. To all the defenders of cliché, wake up, read what is written, (most of which is against against cliché,) there is not a single bit of management of Haifa, only disasters from roads, trash from sidewalks, pigs, animals to cars and more and more,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, enough, just give up the keys. In the elections because you are full of work to do ????

  2. Another anti-Semite, a Jew who hates himself. So according to you, only the ultra-Orthodox benefit. What about the Arabs, what about the shootings? Federation call it...no local laws.
    Stop inciting hatred between Jews.

  3. Shame and shame on Dr. Yariv, a racist opponent. I know what's amazing?
    You admit that the previous government discriminated against the ultra-Orthodox and, on the other hand, discriminated against the residents of Carmel and still presents the change that took place in the disaster.."The ultra-Orthodox receive a rabbit rate" Aalek, apparently you do not control the budgetary area and by the way I remind you that we are in the time of Corona, so how exactly do the ultra-orthedim influence cultural events that do not exist? !?
    You couldn't hide your hatred towards the ultra-Orthodox and your sympathy towards the residents of Carmel and the wealthy population in Haifa between the words... "The new ultra-orthodox city is spreading to the Carmel areas" Oh my tragic disaster!! A real shame that we let someone like you express an opinion
    And the most painful thing is that there are many other residents who support someone like you..

  4. After 33 years in Haifa, my hometown, where I grew up, studied and worked - I am moving with my new family to the Sharon/Parads Hana area.
    Close to Haifa to visit the parents, and also to employment centers in the center, prices quite similar to here, Teva, only without the disgust and neglect thanks to Klish, Yahav, and other clowns to come..
    The restoration of Haifa is a failed project that is no longer relevant. The only populations that settle here are populations from the villages due to population explosion in the Arab villages. There is not much in common between them and the original inhabitants (Jews and Arabs) of the mixed city, and they keep multiplying and changing the character of the city with them. Greater Acre? Much more than that.

    The Matam project is a failure considering the amount of resources and promises. Wait for Intel, a declining company, to start closing offices in Israel and you will see the new neighborhoods in the south of the city empty out, or be replaced by populations that have nothing to do with the character of the city. Those who are smart enough have already left south of the city.
    The ultra-orthodox populations grow and take over huge parts of the city, dictating the rules for those who live in the neighborhood (whose real estate value plummeted at that moment), and around it. Try walking around in a skirt in the area on the outskirts of one of these neighborhoods and you will understand. Try to pass by car on Saturday.

    Everyone before the army, hasn't run away yet. Those who are after the army or university have already run away. After several incarnations, those who stayed/will stay here are the grandparents and those who don't have enough money to move to another city. This is the death spiral of the city in terms of taxes and ability to finance itself.

    Not to mention the organized crime, the violence, etc. from among sharecropper families from the areas that actually live in this city (?!) and continue to destroy, together with elements from the nearby and now distant villages. We have seen that the police are useless against such crime, there is no reason for this to change in the near future.

    In short, Detroit is here.
    At best, we are a crumbling Soviet city (there is some academia, for now, but Zoom will eliminate that too).

  5. In most cases, a Binui removal project makes it possible to put in order the items in the apartment as well as generate an alternative profit that can be generated from the items that are no longer needed. This is especially true in the apartments of older people. As long as there are old items in the apartment such as records, books, old newspapers or any item from the 1950s, there is a situation that these are collectible items with monetary value. If you want to know how to evaluate the contents of the apartment independently, search Google for "clearing the contents of the apartment and collections" and you will arrive at the website of "Yosef Ha'Osef" and get an accurate article that explains how to do this.

The article is closed for comments. You can share online using the share buttons

All the articles are alive

Kiryat Yam: A teenager riding an electric scooter was moderately to seriously injured

(Hai Pa) - Electric scooter accident: On the night between Tuesday and Wednesday, 25/6/25, an electric scooter accident occurred on Jerusalem Boulevard in Kiryat Yam - a boy of about...

Ha'atzmaut Street closed to vehicle traffic for work following the missile strike

Independence Street is closed to vehicle traffic for work to remove danger in nearby buildings following the missile strike. Independence Street continues to be closed to vehicle traffic, in the section between...

Returning from Germany: Goalkeeper Omer Hanin signed for the season with Hapoel Haifa 

In the shadow of the fighting with Iran and with the end of Operation "Am Kalavi" at the Hapoel Haifa Reds football team, preparations continue for the upcoming season...

Ben Gurion and Haifa airports return to full operation • Airports Authority

(Hai Pa) - Flights are returning without restrictions: The restrictions on the number of incoming and outgoing flights, as well as the number of passengers on each flight, have been lifted. In addition, the restrictions on...

Back to routine – the economy is opening – back to school – starting Wednesday, 24/6/25 20:00 PM – all updates

(Live here) - The Home Front Command announces a return to routine, starting from this moment, Tuesday, 24/6/25, 20:00. Full activity in all parts of the country - without restrictions. ...